A new analysis of American household data has mapped out vast marriage deserts across the country, exposing how rare the traditional married, two-parent family has become in many urban cores and parts of the Southeast.
According to The Post Millennial, the Institute for Family Studies (IFS) examined where marriage and married-parent households are thriving and where they are vanishing, using Public Use Microdata Areas (PUMAs), geographic units that generally contain 100,000 to 200,000 individuals each. The findings underscore a widening cultural and social divide between suburban marriage gardens, where marriage remains the norm, and major city centers that have become marriage deserts, with Detroit, Milwaukee, Cleveland, and parts of Washington, DC and Chicago among the most striking examples.
The IFS report focused on householders between the ages of 15 and 64, revealing that suburban regions are far more likely to be anchored by married adults than dense urban cores. The PUMA with the lowest percentage of married householders was Detroit City (South Central and Southeast) in Michigan, where just 13 percent of householders are married, a figure that would have been unthinkable in earlier generations.
Other areas at the bottom of the marriage scale include Milwaukee County, City of Milwaukee Central (WI); Cleveland City (East) and Bratenahl Village (OH); District of Columbia (East, DC); and St. Louis City North (MO). Also listed were Columbus (Central) and Grandview Heights Cities (OH); Atlanta Regional Commission, Fulton County (Central) and Southwest Atlanta City (GA); Cincinnati City in Central Ohio; Boston City (Alston, Brighton and Fenway); and Chicago City (South) (Hyde Park, Grand Boulevard, Woodlawn, Douglas, and Kenwood).
Across these bottom 10 PUMAs, the share of married householders ranges only from 13 percent in Detroit to 17 percent in Chicago, a stark contrast with the healthiest marriage gardens. In those top-performing areas, roughly three-quarters of householders are married, reflecting a social environment far more aligned with the traditional family model that conservatives have long argued is essential for community stability and upward mobility.
The picture is even more troubling when looking specifically at households with children, where marriage is arguably most critical for long-term outcomes. In the leading married-family deserts, only about 18 percent to 26 percent of households with children are headed by married couples, while in married-family gardens that figure soars to between 86 and 89 percent.
Cleveland City (East) and Bratenahl Village (OH) ranks as the lowest PUMA in the nation for married-couple households with children, at just 18 percent. Joining it in the bottom 10 are District of Columbia (East, DC); Milwaukee County, City of Milwaukee Central (WI); Detroit City (South Central and Southeast); Chicago City (South) (Roseland, Chatham, West Pullman, Calumet Heights, and Avalon Park); Atlanta Regional Commission, Fulton County (Central) and Southwest Atlanta City (GA); Chicago City (West) (Austin, North Lawndale, and East/West Garfield Park) (IL); St Louis City (North) (MO); Detroit City (North Central) (MI); and KIPDA Area Development District (Central) (Louisville/Jefferson Co) (KY).
At the other end of the spectrum, the strongest marriage garden in the country is Fort Bend County in Texas, where 79 percent of householders are married, reflecting the kind of family-centered culture conservatives argue should be encouraged nationwide. Ken Burchfiel, a research fellow at the Institute for Family Studies, told Fox News, Marriage and raising kids are both parts of your life that really force you to kind of die to yourself and live for others.
He added, When you have lots of parents, lots of husbands and wives in a region, I imagine just overall the cultural focus is less on 'how can I get ahead in life' and more on 'what can I do for my family? As President Trumps second administration continues to emphasize law, order, and economic renewal, data like this will likely fuel renewed calls from conservatives for policies and cultural shifts that strengthen marriage, support intact families, and push back against the progressive social experiments that have left so many urban communities without the stabilizing presence of married mothers and fathers.
Login