In a recent development, New York State Attorney General Letitia James has initiated a legal battle against a Nassau County law that prohibits transgender athletes from participating in women and girls sports at county-owned athletic facilities.
The lawsuit was filed immediately after Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman, a Republican, signed the legislation into law. The legislation, which was passed by the local Republican-led legislature last month, has stirred controversy and sparked a heated debate.
According to The New York Post, Blakeman initially attempted to enforce the ban on biological males identifying as females participating in women's sports through an executive order. However, this directive was dismissed in court following a lawsuit filed by the New York Civil Liberties Union (NYCLU) on behalf of the Long Island Roller Rebels. Now, Democrat James has joined the legal fray in the second round against the transgender ban, aligning herself with the NYCLU, which has filed a separate lawsuit challenging the law in Nassau County Supreme Court.
Blakeman, during a press conference on Monday, argued that it is unjust for trans women and girls to compete against biological females, citing scientific evidence that biological males are generally stronger, bigger, and faster than women. "We're protecting the integrity, fairness, and safety in women's sports. It's a matter of common sense," he stated. He also mentioned that Caitlyn Jenner, one of the world's most renowned transgender individuals and a former athlete, supports the ban. "She stood here with us and said, `You're doing the right thing,'" Blakeman quoted Jenner as saying.
However, James contends that the Nassau ban contravenes New York laws that prohibit discrimination based on a resident's gender identity or expression. "With this law, Nassau County is once again attempting to exclude transgender girls and women from participating in sporting events while claiming to support fairness," James said in a statement accompanying the lawsuit. She further added, "Here in New York, every person has the right to be exactly who they are free from discrimination, and my office will always protect that right.
Gabriella Lario, a staff attorney at NYCLU, criticized Nassau County's "relentless efforts to shut transgender women and girls out of sports," stating that it will leave a lasting stain on elected officials. "This latest round of hateful legislation is unacceptable and we won't let it stand in New York," Lario declared while announcing the group's own lawsuit against the ban.
The legal tussle in Nassau reflects the broader national debate over transgender athletes competing against women, with conservatives generally supporting bans and liberals opposing them. Blakeman stated on Monday that he has not encountered any opposition from the LGBT community in Nassau, and he has received specific support from lesbian athletes for the ban. "There are a few people out there with a narrow view who say this is an anti-transgender bill and it's not," he asserted.
A poll conducted by Siena College in April revealed that 66% of New York voters support a ban on transgender athletes competing against girls, with only 27% opposing "requiring high school athletes to only compete with others of the same sex that they were assigned at birth." The poll found strong support for the prohibition across party, racial, ethnic, and regional lines, with only voters identifying themselves as "liberal" opposing the ban.
This ongoing legal battle underscores the complexities and sensitivities surrounding the issue of transgender athletes' participation in sports. As the debate continues, the outcome of this lawsuit could have significant implications for the future of sports and transgender rights in New York and beyond.
Login