What Really Happens When Teachers Are Allowed To Carry Guns In School? A 25-Year Study Gives Us The Answer

Written by Published

Schools that let teachers carry guns have gone a quarter century without a single attack causing a shooting death or injury, a new study found.

John R. Lott Jr., president of the Crime Prevention Research Center, reviewed school shootings from 2000 through 2025, according to The Washington Times. He found no mass shootings and no shooting-related deaths or injuries during or near school hours in buildings where staff are allowed to be armed, counting both attacks and accidental discharges.

The record was not entirely spotless. Lott found one suicide in 2001 by a student who brought his own gun, and one teacher hurt in 2014 when her gun went off in a bathroom and fragments from a porcelain toilet struck her.

He found no case of a student getting hold of a teacher's or staff member's gun and hurting someone. That outperformed schools that ban guns and even campuses guarded by police or paid security.

The findings cut against one of the central warnings from gun control advocates, who argue that more guns in schools will mean more shootings. "We don't need to guess. We have decades of experience with many thousands of schools that have this right now," Lott said.

"The fact that with all of the experience you have, you can't point to any problems. I think it's pretty startling," he added.

He argued that armed-staff schools look even better when compared with the alternatives. Schools with official security, either a police officer or a paid guard, make up about 45% of the nation's total, and Lott counted 39 attacks with casualties at those schools over the period studied.

Schools that allow no armed presence at all account for roughly 42% of campuses. They fared worst in the data, with 551 incidents involving casualties.

Lott also tallied 20 cases of police officers accidentally firing their guns, six accidental discharges by private security guards and two cases where security officers' weapons fired during a struggle. In one more case, a student grabbed a school resource officer's pistol and accidentally fired it.

He also identified three cases in which police shot someone other than their intended target or may have mistaken a bystander for a threat. Accidental discharges simply were not a problem among armed teachers.

"When you look at this, they just don't occur. There's not one case where a teacher has either accidentally or on purpose, out of rage, shot somebody. There's no case where a student has gotten ahold of a gun and done something bad," he said.

The push to arm teachers gained momentum after the 1999 Columbine High School massacre in Colorado and again after the 2012 Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting in Connecticut. A 2018 report from the Federal Commission on School Safety urged schools to "seriously consider" training and arming faculty and staff.

Gun control groups and national Democrats have pushed back hard. Everytown for Gun Safety says on its website that teachers cannot be expected to make sound decisions "in a moment of extreme duress and confusion," adding, "The notion of a highly trained teacher armed with a gun, able to respond as quickly as trained law enforcement, is a myth."

Giffords, the gun control group founded by former Arizona Rep. Gabrielle Giffords, released its own report in 2021 listing dozens of incidents involving guns brought to school by teachers, staff, parents, police officers or security guards. That report, covering 2014 to 2021, did not separate people authorized to carry from those who were not.

The incidents ranged from misplaced guns found by students to accidental discharges, arguments and suicides. One teacher's gun fell from his waistband while he was helping elementary students do cartwheels, though no shots were fired.

Another case involved a substitute teacher in Alabama in 2019 whose gun went off in a first-grade classroom, sending a student to the nurse after being hit by a fragment. According to a news account, that teacher was not authorized to carry the gun.

"Arming teachers is an incredibly unpopular proposition, opposed by seven out of ten teenagers, eight out of ten teachers, and seven out of ten parents. And for good reason," the Giffords group concluded.

Lott's team pulled lockdown and shooting reports from multiple databases and identified 1,057 cases of gunfire on school property, from accidents and suicides to gang shootings. Researchers then worked to determine whether each school had a staff carry policy, a police officer or security guard, or no knowing allowance for guns.

Shooting deaths on campuses have climbed over the 25 years covered. In the early years they generally stayed at or below a dozen annually, but in the 2020s they have ranged from 18 to 51 a year.

The deadliest year in the data was 2018, with 52 deaths. Across the entire study, Lott found just one death at a school that let teachers carry, and it was the 2001 suicide.