Legendary folk singer Joni Mitchell is discovering that, for many on the contemporary Left, open affection for the United States is treated less as a virtue than as a provocation.
Mitchell announced on Tuesday that, after more than six decades of residence, she had finally become an American citizen. According to RedState, she shared a brief video of her name being called at what appeared to be a small naturalization ceremony inside a Department of Homeland Security office, along with a photograph of herself beaming, a small American flag in hand, standing before larger U.S. and DHS flags.
She made clear that this was the culmination of a long personal journey, captioning her post, A journey that began 62 years ago. For a woman whose music has long been woven into the cultural fabric of North America, the moment was plainly significant and deeply personal.
Yet the reaction from many progressives was swift, bitter, and revealing. Rather than applauding a legal immigrant embracing American citizenship, left-wing users on X rushed to mock her decision and smear her motives.
Willingly applying for American citizenship at this moment in historyoh MAGA Mitchell, one person sneered on X. Another dismissed her entirely with the curt rebuke, Talk about being tone deaf.
Some of the harshest responses came from north of the border. I don't think many Canadian are happy for you on this achievement, one commenter sniffed, before adding, Though we still love your music.
Others dispensed with even that courtesy. One declared, Off my playlist! while another erupted with a jab of nationalist pique: Haha traitor elbows up!
Amid the vitriol, many Americans responded with warmth, welcoming Mitchell as a fellow citizen regardless of political differences. For conservatives who still believe in the ideal of a lawful, orderly immigration process, an immigrant who's happy to be here and went through the correct process to obtain citizenship is precisely the kind of story worth celebrating.
Even her former partner Graham Nash joined in, writing, Congrats, Joan! Just in time to vote! As the article wryly noted, I guess you could say she's seen the reactions from both sides now, eh?
No one seriously expects Mitchell to cast her first ballot for a Republican, let alone for President Donald Trump, but that is beside the point. The real story is that she has freely chosen to embrace American citizenshipand in a nation built on individual liberty, that choice, and the right to vote as she wishes, is exactly what makes the United States worth defending.
Login