Sanctuary judges across the country are on notice after the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court issued a rare formal reprimand to Judge Shelley Joseph for her role in helping an illegal alien avoid Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), according to the Department of Homeland Securitys (DHS) top lawyer.
The case, as reported by Breitbart News, centers on an April 2018 incident involving illegal alien Oscar Manuel Peguero, who also used the alias Jose Medina-Perez, after he was arrested in Massachusetts on drug possession charges while wanted as a fugitive from justice in Pennsylvania. ICE had lodged a detainer against Peguero the same day he was arrested, and federal agents waited outside Josephs courtroom prepared to take him into custody, but the detainer was ignored.
Prosecutors say Joseph allowed Peguero to leave through a rear exit, enabling him to slip past the ICE officers who were positioned to arrest him, an extraordinary move that led to her indictment the following year on charges of conspiracy to obstruct justice, aiding and abetting obstruction of justice, and aiding and abetting obstruction of a federal proceeding. Under the Biden administration, those criminal charges were dropped in 2022, a decision that critics argue reflects a broader pattern of leniency toward those who frustrate federal immigration enforcement.
On September 10, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court opted for a formal reprimand instead of more serious discipline, concluding that Joseph created an appearance of impropriety in violation of her duties when she ordered the courtroom audio recording turned off during the episode. For many conservatives, that sanction underscores how the judiciary in deep-blue states often shields its own while illegal immigration continues to strain public resources and undermine the rule of law.
DHS General Counsel James Percival told Breitbart News that the ruling sends a clear warning to activist jurists who treat federal immigration law as optional. This judicial misconduct reflects what DHS is facing across the country, Percival said.
Certain judges think it is their duty to undermine, rather than enforce, federal immigration law. Helping illegal aliens escape from immigration officers is a felony. Sanctuary politicians and sanctuary judges alike are on notice. Pegueros own record illustrates the stakes: he first entered the United States illegally in January 2003 by flying into Boston and falsely claiming to be an American citizen, was arrested that same month, and deported.
He returned in April 2007 by illegally crossing the southern border through New Mexico, was arrested by Border Patrol, and deported again in June 2007 before making yet another unlawful reentry at an unknown later date. As the nation continues to grapple with border chaos unleashed by President Joe Bidens policies, the Joseph case highlights a growing clash between federal law and local sanctuary practices and whether judges who side with illegal aliens over American sovereignty will finally face meaningful accountability.
Login