Retired Major General Randy Manner sharply rebuked President Donald Trump and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth on Friday, accusing the nations top civilian leaders of spewing lies about deteriorating conditions aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln.
The controversy centers on the aircraft carriers extended deployment in the Iran conflict, which began in November and was initially slated to conclude in May but has now dragged on for months beyond that window. According to Mediaite, sailors and their families have described a grim reality at sea, citing exhaustion, homesickness, shortages of food and supplies, and what they view as inadequate support from military leadership.
One particularly harrowing episode involved a 19-year-old sailor who jumped overboard on August 3, an incident his wife described to MS NOW as a suicide attempt. She said he spent roughly an hour in the water before being rescued, a detail that has intensified concerns about the mental and emotional strain on the crew.
Hegseth has forcefully rejected these accounts as completely misrepresented, accusing the media on Friday of deliberately distorting conditions aboard the Lincoln. He insisted that its sailors are very proud of their mission, framing the criticism as part of a broader narrative war against the administrations handling of national security.
President Trump, for his part, dismissed the mounting concerns, asserting that families are not truly worried about their loved ones aboard the ship and insisting the sailors have been deployed not nearly long enough. That posture reflects a more hardline view of military endurance and commitment, but it has also sparked backlash from some within the defense community who see it as dismissive of legitimate hardship.
Manner, appearing on CNNs program with host Erin Burnett, said the presidents totally inappropriate remarks would have gotten him relieved within minutes had he been a uniformed officer. The retired generals criticism carries added weight given that Trump received five draft deferments during the Vietnam War four for college and a fifth for a medical diagnosis of bone spurs in his heels.
Pressed on how he believes the president and Hegseths rhetoric will affect morale, Manner did not mince words. It negatively impacts morale. I used to say that the president and the secretary of defense were spewing propaganda. Unfortunately, now theyre actually spewing lies, he said, arguing that honest leadership is essential to sustaining the force.
Manner contended that a responsible chain of command would respond with openness rather than denial. In the interest of transparency, any good commander would say, We are deploying a team immediately to land on the USS Abraham Lincoln to assess the situation, and to ensure that we properly address the issues that are there, and we will bring media with us in all transparency. This administration wants to say, Theres nothing to see here. All the families are lying. There are no issues on it. And that is absolutely not the case, he argued.
While CNNs Pamela Brown reported Thursday that the USS George Washington has been dispatched to relieve the Lincoln, she noted that no firm timeline has been given for when that relief will actually arrive. Adding to the tension, the wife of a service member aboard the carrier told CNNs Jake Tapper that the president and defense secretarys assurances were infuriating, underscoring a widening gap between official statements and the lived experience of families bearing the burden of extended war.
Login