Joe Biden sparked a fierce backlash over the weekend with a Fourth of July message that many critics saw as yet another attempt to lecture Americans rather than honor their countrys founding.
The controversy erupted after Biden, or more likely a staffer, posted a statement marking the 250th anniversary of American independence, in which he declared that America is just an idea and chastised citizens for failing to fully live up to the Declaration of Independence, according to Gateway Pundit. Conservatives quickly seized on the tone of the message, arguing that at a moment meant to celebrate American greatness, the White House instead chose to emphasize national shortcomings and vague rhetoric about democracy rather than the concrete liberties secured by the Founders.
Bidens statement opened with a familiar progressive framing of the nations birth, saying, Two hundred and fifty years ago, a group of Americans signed their names to a piece of parchment and made a promise no nation had ever made before: that were all created equal, endowed by our Creator with unalienable rights life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. He then asserted, Were the only nation in history built not on ethnicity, or blood, or geography but on an idea. Thats always been what makes us exceptional. We chose that path 250 years ago but thats where the work began, not where it ended. Every generation has had to choose it again. At Valley Forge, at Gettysburg, on the beaches of Normandy, in the streets of Selma. Americans recommitted themselves to the principles on which our nation was founded.
From there, Biden shifted to a familiar theme of fragility and struggle, insisting, Now its our turn. He warned, Theres nothing guaranteed about our democracy. We have to fight for it, defend it, and earn it. Over and over, year after year. Thats not a burden. Thats what it means to be an American.
The most contentious passage came when Biden declared, 250 years in, we still havent fully lived up to those words in the Declaration. But weve never walked away from them, and this July 4, I hope all of us can commit to one thing: that we never will. I dont believe were as divided as were told we are. Ive bet my whole life on the American people, and Im not stopping now. He closed with a perfunctory greeting: Happy 250th birthday, America. Our story isnt finished. Lets keep writing it together.
For many on the right, the message encapsulated a broader pattern in the Biden era: a reluctance to unapologetically celebrate the nations achievements, paired with constant moralizing about democracy and division. While President Donald Trump and other conservatives typically use Independence Day to highlight American strength, sacrifice, and exceptionalism in concrete terms, Bidens critics argued that this years Freedom 250 remarks sounded more like a civics lecture than a patriotic tribute, which is why, as Gateway Pundit reported, Biden was swiftly roasted for what many viewed as an anti-American Fourth of July message.
Login