The Vaticans latest attempt to cool tensions between Pope Leo XIV and Donald Trump has done little to conceal a widening rift between the American pontiffs rhetoric and the instincts of many conservative believers who once formed the backbone of Trumps political base.
During a visit to Cameroon, Pope Leo XIV insisted that his recent warning that the world is being ravaged by tyrants was not aimed at the president, despite the timing of his remarks following Trumps furious attacks over the Popes criticism of the war in Iran. According to the Daily Mail, the 70-year-old pontiff, the first American ever to lead the Roman Catholic Church, has been forced into damage-control mode after his unusually sharp language was widely interpreted as a veiled rebuke of Trumps foreign policy and his combative style.
Leo had used his African tour to condemn political leaders who invoke religious language to justify conflict, urging instead a decisive change of course away from war. Yet he now says he regrets that his reference to tyrants was read as a direct response to Trumps broadsides, stressing that he has no desire to be drawn into a personal feud with the Republican standard-bearer.
The Pope maintained that his comments were drafted long before Trumps latest outburst over Iran and the Vaticans peace appeals. The remarks, he said, predated Trumps comment on myself and on the message of peace that I am promoting, suggesting that any linkage between the two was a media construction rather than his intention.
And yet it was perceived as if I were trying to start a new debate with the president, which doesn't interest me at all, Leo said, signalling his wish to avoid becoming a protagonist in American electoral politics. Much of what has been written since then has been more commentary on commentary trying to interpret what has been said, he added, lamenting the spiralling cycle of speculation that has followed each exchange.
Leo, who arrived in Angola on Friday on the third leg of a four-nation African tour, has used the trip to advance a message of social solidarity and human dignity. In his homily, delivered in French, he described respect for the human person as the bedrock of any just society and called for practical structures of mutual support.
For this reason, every community has the obligation to create and sustain structures of solidarity and mutual aid in which, when faced with crises - be they social, political, medical or economic - everyone can give and receive assistance according to their own capacity and needs, he said, framing his appeal in terms that echo Catholic social teaching but also risk being read as a critique of Western power politics. That broader moral language has collided head-on with Trumps more muscular approach to national security, particularly regarding Irans nuclear ambitions.
Trump, speaking on April 12, declared he was not a big fan of Pope Leo, accusing the pontiff of toying with a country (Iran) that wants a nuclear weapon. He then escalated his criticism on Truth Social, writing: I don't want a Pope who thinks it's OK for Iran to have a Nuclear Weapon, casting Leo as dangerously nave on one of the most volatile issues in global security.
Pope Leo is WEAK on Crime, and terrible for Foreign Policy, the president continued, tying his critique of the Pope to familiar campaign themes of law and order and American strength abroad. Trump further claimed Leo was elevated to the papacy because he was an American, adding, If I wasn't in the White House , Leo wouldn't be in the Vatican.
He went on: I don't think he's doing a very good job. He likes crime I guess. Trump then sharpened his attack on the Popes moral authority, saying: We don't like a Pope who says it's ok to have a nuclear weapon. We don't want a Pope that says crime is ok. I am not a fan of Pope Leo.
The clash took an even more incendiary turn when Trump posted an AI-generated image that appeared to depict himself as Jesus Christ, a move that outraged many Christians who otherwise share his conservative politics. He later deleted the image, claiming he had meant to portray himself as a doctor, but the damage among some religious supporters was already done.
Although Trump has long been known for his willingness to berate foreign leaders and domestic critics alike, his open confrontation with the Pope has unsettled parts of his own base. Many of his most loyal voters are conservative Catholics who, while often wary of the Vaticans recent leftward drift on climate, migration, and economics, still regard the papacy as a sacred office deserving of respect.
Trump loyalist Shane Schaetzel, an author from Missouri who backed him in 2016, 2020 and 2024, said he had finally had enough. I've been very patient and very balanced in the feud erupting between him and the Pope. This, however, is too much. Donald Trump just lost my support, he told The Times, adding that he had cancelled his Truth Social subscription and sold his Trump-related stocks.
Former congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene, once one of Trumps fiercest defenders in Congress, also broke ranks over the episode. On Orthodox Easter, President Trump attacked the Pope because the Pope is rightly against Trump's war in Iran and then he posted this picture of himself as if he is replacing Jesus, she wrote, highlighting the timing and symbolism that many Christians found deeply offensive.
This comes after last week's post of his evil tirade on Easter and then threatening to kill an entire civilisation. I completely denounce this and I'm praying against it!!! Greene added, in language that underscored the spiritual stakes she sees in Trumps rhetoric. It's more than blasphemy, she wrote from a second account. It's an Antichrist spirit.
Other figures within the MAGA movement voiced similar alarm at the messianic overtones of the AI image. Oh hell no, wrote hard-Right provocateur Milo Yiannopoulos, who has long embraced provocative online tactics but balked at this latest step.
We tolerated this kind of meme against our better judgment because he promised to save America and only when it was clear he didn't actually think he was the Messiah, Yiannopoulos said, suggesting that some supporters now fear Trump may be internalising the cult of personality that once merely amused them. Right-wing commentator Mike Cernovich likewise objected, writing on X: Trump's first post was fine. The Pope has a long documented political record. The follow-up posts? Would not be tolerated for any other religion.
Yet even as some on the Right recoil, others have rushed to defend Trump and redirect criticism toward the Vatican. Republican House Speaker Mike Johnson argued that the Pope had invited political blowback by venturing into debates over war and peace in ways that appeared to target a U.S. president.
Johnson said he was taken a little bit aback by Leos suggestion that those who engage in war, that Jesus doesn't hear their prayers or something. It is a very well-settled matter of Christian theology, there's something called the just war doctrine, he added, implicitly accusing the Pope of oversimplifying a complex moral tradition that has long allowed for the legitimate use of force.
Texas Congressman Troy Nehls went further, bluntly telling the Pope to stay out of politics during remarks on Wednesday. The Pope needs to keep his business to leading his flock, leading the church, and stay out of the political arena, Nehls said, reflecting a widespread conservative concern that the Vatican has drifted into progressive activism.
Go lead your church. Stay out of politics. We didn't elect the Pope to be the president. Donald Trump is our president, he added, crystallizing the sentiment of many on the Right who, while uneasy with Trumps more theatrical provocations, still see him as a necessary counterweight to what they view as an increasingly politicized and left-leaning papacy. As Pope Leo XIV continues his African tour preaching solidarity and peace, the unresolved question for many conservative Catholics is whether their spiritual shepherd can speak forcefully on global affairs without appearing to take sides in Americas most polarising political battle.
Login