In a recent Supreme Court hearing, Justice Amy Coney Barrett, a Trump appointee, engaged in a heated exchange with U.S. Solicitor General John Sauer.
The discussion centered on the Trump administration's adherence to federal court precedents, a topic that has been a source of contention among Trump's allies. This dialogue, which took place on Thursday, has been one of the most discussed events of the day and could potentially reignite criticism of Barrett from Trump's supporters.
The verbal sparring occurred during oral arguments in a case concerning President Donald Trump's attempt to terminate birthright citizenship. The case specifically focused on the power of lower courts to prevent executive actions from being implemented nationwide, as reported by Fox News.
Justice Barrett questioned Sauer about the administration's approach to lower court rulings, echoing similar inquiries from her fellow justices.
Justice Barrett initiated the conversation by highlighting a perceived inconsistency in Sauer's responses to her colleagues, Justices Kavanaugh and Kagan. She questioned whether the Trump administration intended to maintain its right to possibly disregard a Second Circuit precedent, particularly if it disagreed with the ruling.
"You resisted Justice Kagan when she asked you whether the government would obey" such a precedent, Barrett pointed out. Sauer responded by stating that while the administration generally respects precedents, there are instances when this is not the case.
Interrupting Sauer, Barrett sought clarification on whether this was a practice specific to the Trump administration or a long-standing practice of the federal government. Sauer confirmed that it was a long-standing policy of the Department of Justice, a response that seemed to surprise Justice Barrett.
The conversation then shifted to the recent ruling by the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, which declared Trump's birthright citizenship order unconstitutional. Barrett questioned Sauer on the administration's response to such rulings, to which Sauer replied that they generally follow them. This response elicited a somewhat incredulous reaction from Barrett.
The exchange sparked a flurry of divided political reactions on social media. Democratic strategist Max Burns noted that Sauer's comments suggested that the Trump administration reserves the right to disregard legal opinions it disagrees with. Seth Taylor, a 2024 DNC delegate, criticized the Trump team for potentially ignoring lower court rulings unless directly addressed by the Supreme Court.
On the other hand, conservative commentator and podcast host Cash Loren criticized Justice Barrett, suggesting that she might be the worst Supreme Court pick by a Republican. Loren pointed out Barrett's lifetime appointment to the Supreme Court and her apparent disdain for the Trump administration.
Earlier this year, Barrett joined three liberal justices and Chief Justice John Roberts in rejecting the Trump administration's request to block billions in USAID money for previously completed projects. This decision drew sharp criticism from Trump supporters, who labeled Justice Barrett an "activist" justice and accused her of being disloyal to the president who nominated her.
Despite the criticism, others have highlighted Barrett's consistent conservative voting record and the lifetime appointment of justices, which is intended to prevent undue political interference. President Trump, when asked about the attacks against Barrett, expressed ignorance and praised her as a "very good woman."
The court's decision on the birthright citizenship case could be announced in the coming days or weeks. According to George Washington University law professor Jonathan Turley, the outcome will likely depend heavily on the votes of two Trump appointees, Justice Neil Gorsuch and Justice Barrett.
Turley described the hearing as "sporty," with some "lively moments," and identified Gorsuch and Barrett as the justices to watch. He also noted that Justice Barrett is currently the greatest concern for the Trump administration.
Login