In a potential election rematch this November between President Biden and former President Donald Trump, the specter of a one-term presidency looms large for one of these political figures.
Former President Trump, who was defeated by Biden in 2020, is now seeking to turn the tables in 2024. Meanwhile, President Biden finds himself grappling with lackluster approval ratings akin to those of the infamous one-term President Jimmy Carter. As of February, Biden's job approval rating stood at a mere 38% in a Gallup poll, just slightly above Carter's record-low Gallup rating of 37.4% after his third year in office.
Comparisons between Biden's current standing and Carter's position in 1980, when he lost re-election to Republican Ronald Reagan, suggest that Biden may be in a weaker position. In March 1980, a Gallup poll showed Carter leading Reagan by a significant margin, but as the election drew closer, Reagan closed the gap and ultimately secured a decisive victory over Carter.
While there is no direct Gallup survey for Biden and Trump in 2024, recent polls indicate a closely contested race. Trump currently holds a slight lead of 2.1 points over Biden in the RealClearPolitics average of polls. A Fox News Poll released recently showed Trump at 49% support, with Biden closely trailing at 47%, indicating a statistical tie within the margin of sampling error.
Reflecting on the past, Craig Shirley, a biographer of Reagan, highlighted the early lead Carter held over Reagan in 1980, attributing it to public sympathy and support during the Iranian hostage crisis. The crisis, which began in 1979, involved the seizure of the U.S. embassy in Tehran by radicalized students protesting Carter's decision to admit the deposed Shah of Iran into the U.S. for medical treatment. The prolonged hostage situation, lasting 444 days, tested Carter's leadership as efforts to secure the hostages' release proved unsuccessful.
Shirley noted that public sentiment shifted as people began to perceive Carter's handling of the crisis as politically motivated. The failure to resolve the hostage crisis before the election dealt a significant blow to Carter's re-election prospects.
Carter's bid for a second term was further complicated by economic challenges, including high inflation and unemployment rates, a combination known as "stagflation." The economic woes, coupled with the ongoing Iran crisis, painted a grim picture of Carter's presidency.
Drawing parallels to the present, President Biden faces his own set of domestic and foreign policy crises. Despite touting an economic "comeback," inflation remains a pressing concern, with the latest consumer price index report showing a year-over-year increase of 3.2%. The inflation surge, exacerbated by pandemic-related spending packages, has strained household budgets, particularly impacting low-income Americans.
On the foreign policy front, Biden's handling of crises in Afghanistan, Ukraine, and Israel has drawn criticism, with public support waning following the chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan and ongoing conflicts in the Middle East. The unresolved hostage situation involving Americans held by Hamas adds to Biden's challenges on the international stage.
In contrast, former President Trump faces legal hurdles of his own as he navigates multiple criminal charges and indictments, including cases related to his actions post-2020 election. Despite these legal battles, Trump remains a formidable contender in the upcoming election, aiming to capitalize on issues such as illegal immigration and inflation to challenge Biden's leadership.
To secure a victory akin to Reagan's in 1980, Trump must position himself as a viable alternative to Biden, focusing on key issues that resonate with voters. Shirley emphasized the importance of Trump making Biden the focal point of the campaign, leveraging his experience as a former president to present himself as a capable leader ready to address the nation's challenges.
As the election season unfolds, the dynamics between Biden and Trump will continue to evolve, shaping the narrative of the race and influencing voter perceptions. The echoes of past presidencies and the weight of current crises underscore the high stakes of the upcoming election, where the outcome could determine the trajectory of the nation for years to come.
Login