In a recent editorial, The Harvard Crimson's editorial board expressed concerns over Harvard University's revamped college application process, arguing that it could disadvantage individuals from "marginalized backgrounds."
The university's new application format has shifted from one optional open-ended essay and two short essays to five compulsory short essays.
The editorial board took issue with the 200-word limit imposed on the new essay responses, arguing that it is an unrealistic constraint. They believe that students will struggle to encapsulate their experiences and backgrounds within such a limited word count.
The board wrote, "Shortening the essays has a disparate impact that falls heaviest on those from marginalized backgrounds. Learning to package yourself within a shorter amount of space is a product of advanced education; longer essays more equitably allow applicants to discuss their experiences in full, particularly if they are from non-traditional backgrounds and require more space to elaborate on nuanced qualifications."
The board also highlighted the uncertainty surrounding the role of diverse backgrounds in the application process, especially in light of the cessation of race-based affirmative action in university admissions. They noted, "'Briefly describe an intellectual experience that was important to you.' This question seemingly privileges applicants from well-resourced backgrounds for whom additional academic opportunities were plentiful in high school."
Institutions like Johns Hopkins University have been utilizing identity-focused questions in their application essays as a workaround to the Supreme Court's ban on race-based admissions. Meanwhile, the Biden administration has encouraged colleges to consider how a student's race could contribute to campus diversity and to target programs that promote diversity.
The editorial board concluded by expressing regret over the loss of Harvard's old application process, but acknowledged the university's efforts to maintain a diverse student body.
They stated, "As the Class of 2028 gets to writing, we mourn the loss of Harvards old application. However, the focus on retaining a diverse student body in the questions Harvard asks its applicants is a welcome supplement."
Login