A heated exchange erupted on social media between former MSNBC and ESPN host Keith Olbermann and two-time All-SEC first-team swimmer Riley Gaines.
The dispute was sparked by Olbermann's disparaging comments about Gaines' swimming abilities, which he shared on X, the social media platform formerly known as Twitter.
Olbermann's contentious remarks were made in response to Gaines' advocacy for the exclusion of transgender women from female sports. The former television host labeled Gaines a "homophobe" and dismissed her as a "second team all-conference" swimmer. Gaines, who hosts the "Gaines for Girls" podcast on OutKick, has been vocal about this issue.
Gaines, a decorated athlete with an impressive collegiate resume, was quick to defend her achievements. In a video response to Olbermann's post, she showcased her numerous accolades, which include All-SEC first-team honors, three SEC titles, a second-place finish nationally, an SEC community service award, and the SEC female scholar-athlete of the year award. She also qualified for the U.S. trials for the Tokyo Olympics.
The feud was ignited by Olbermann's response to a post by Gaines on X, in which he suggested that her lack of swimming prowess was the reason she "lost" to Lia Thomas, a transgender swimmer who won a Division I championship in 2022. Gaines retorted, "Ah, makes sense now why you got fired from ESPN."
Paula Scanlan, a former teammate of Thomas at Penn, came to Gaines' defense. Scanlan criticized Olbermann for his dismissive views, which she argued embolden men to invade women's spaces. She urged him to acknowledge the reality of women's spaces being encroached upon and the harm caused by this narrative.
In an op-ed for The Telegraph, Scanlan expressed her disappointment with the #MeToo movement and other women's organizations in the U.S., accusing them of being absorbed into the Democratic Party.
She shared her personal experience of having to "relive" the trauma of her sexual assault due to undressing in front of Thomas. Scanlan argued that the issue of sexual assault by transgender women has been largely overlooked by women's organizations.
Login