Florida Grandmother Run Over By Illegal Immigrant In Publix Lot Prosecutors' Decision Leaves Her Family Furious

Written by Published

Florida prosecutors have dropped the case against an illegal immigrant who backed an SUV over an 82-year-old grandmother in a Publix parking lot.

Larry Basford, state attorney for Florida's Fourteenth Judicial Circuit, said the driver will face no charges for the death of Deborah Murphy. "I think everyone would agree that what he did was careless and it was negligent," Basford told Fox News Digital, but "not every tragedy amounts to a crime."

Murphy had made a quick stop at the Publix in Panama City Beach and was walking back to her car with a bag. Surveillance video shows her crossing in the crosswalk, facing away, when a Toyota 4Runner moving in reverse struck her.

The SUV knocked her to the ground and kept going. It continued backing up, "running over Ms. Murphy," according to an arrest affidavit from the Florida Highway Patrol.

She died from blunt force injuries less than an hour later, her daughters said. The driver, 26-year-old Venezuelan national Carlos Suarez-Contreras, was in the country illegally and was driving on a canceled Georgia license, according to arrest records.

He was first charged with driving with a canceled license and causing a death, a third-degree felony. He was held without bond because of his immigration status and because officials considered him a "potential flight risk."

Prosecutors spent nearly six months on the case. "We tried not to leave any stone unturned," Basford said.

The license issue turned out to be the sticking point. Investigators found that the Georgia license became invalid only a day before the crash, and Georgia officials would not say when Suarez-Contreras would have been notified.

"Under the law, we have to prove that the individual knew his license was suspended," Basford explained. Prosecutors also weighed vehicular homicide and manslaughter but could not establish the culpable negligence those charges require.

Investigators re-enacted the scene using the surveillance footage. They concluded the SUV was not backing up fast enough to prove the driver acted "recklessly."

A Florida law passed in 2023 invalidates licenses that certain states, such as California, Connecticut and Delaware, issue to illegal immigrants. Georgia is not on that list of "those liberal states that gave licenses out so freely to individuals," Basford said.

Murphy's family is heartbroken. "We feel incredibly let down by the state of Florida, who vowed to seek justice on her behalf," her daughter Amy Edge said. "It's like experiencing the loss all over again."

Edge said her mother was in great health and should have had many more years with her family. She will now miss her grandchildren's weddings and never meet more of her great-grandchildren. "That's been taken away," Edge said.

The family questions how the death was investigated and why the re-enactment carried so much weight. They also want to know why the driver was not tested for drugs or alcohol and why his phone records were not reviewed.

"We know the man killed her," Edge said. "He never got out of the car. He never ran to her aid."

Edge and her twin sister, Beth Schulz, say they may push for changes to state law or to how such crashes are investigated. "There's a lot of different questions we have that we'll continue to explore, but not in a vengeful way," Edge said. It is "more in that we don't want this to happen to someone else."

Suarez-Contreras has since been transferred to ICE custody to await deportation, which offers the family some comfort. "We don't want him to be able to do this to anyone else in the United States. Our drive now is to ensure that he is deported," Edge said.

His defense attorney, Russell Ramey, said he is pleased the charges were dropped. A passenger in the vehicle, who was found to have an expired visa, was also released into ICE custody.