New Jersey lawmakers are weighing a first-in-the-nation bill to legally define "Islamophobia," and critics warn it could chill criticism of Islam.
The measure, Assembly Bill A1146, is sponsored by Democratic Assemblyman Joe Danielsen, according to The Algemeiner. It would require public officials and police to weigh that definition when deciding whether an alleged violation of state anti-discrimination law was motivated by bias.
The bill describes Islamophobia as "a type of racism that targets expressions of Muslimness or perceived Muslimness." It then lists 13 examples of conduct that could fall under the label.
Some examples cover plainly unlawful acts such as assaults, threats and harassment. Others reach much further, and that is where opponents say the trouble begins.
Mike Gonzalez of The Heritage Foundation argued in The Daily Signal that the proposal amounts to "a blasphemy law in disguise." He contends the definitions are so broad they would make it nearly impossible to evaluate Islam or its political dimension in any meaningful way.
Gonzalez zeroed in on the bill's closing clause, which reads in part that "a public official or law enforcement officer shall take into consideration the definition of Islamophobia." The language applies when authorities are "determining whether the alleged act was motivated by Islamophobia and discriminatory anti-Muslim intent."
Among the listed examples, Islamophobia includes "hatred or severe disparagement towards Muslim persons or their culture." Another covers "hostility and fear of Islam, and as a result, a fear of and aversion to all Muslims or the majority of Muslims."
A further provision targets "accusing Muslim citizens of being more loyal to a transnational Muslim community or to their countries of origin." Gonzalez argued that such wording would make it difficult to debate questions about the foreign policy views of elected officials.
The bill does not create a new crime or make it illegal on its own to criticize the Quran. But New Jersey's bias-intimidation statute can raise criminal penalties when bias is found, so critics fear the definition could shape how motive is judged in criminal cases.
The legislation is backed by the Council on American-Islamic Relations, according to Gonzalez. He noted that Texas and Florida have labeled CAIR a "foreign terrorist organization" over its alleged association with the Muslim Brotherhood, a charge the group rejects.
The sponsors openly say their definitions were "modeled in part after the All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG), which is composed of British Parliament Members." Britain has wrestled for years over whether such definitions suppress free speech.
Gonzalez quoted French anthropologist Florence Bergeaud-Blackler, who warned of the effect on public debate. "If this law passes, accusations of Islamophobia could be used to equate any criticism of Islam or Islamism with an attack on Muslims," she said.
"Fear of being accused of Islamophobia could lead journalists, researchers, and anyone who speaks critically about Islam in public debate to censor themselves," Bergeaud-Blackler added. Republican Assemblyman Paul Kanitra has also objected to the bill on free speech grounds.
Supporters counter that a uniform definition would help officials recognize and respond to discrimination against Muslims. They point to FBI data showing Muslims were the targets of a disproportionate share of religion-based hate crimes relative to their population.
If A1146 becomes law, legal challenges under the First Amendment are widely expected. Whether they would succeed is far from certain.
Login