Two former top NYPD officials say Mayor Zohran Mamdani's plan to dismantle the department's protest response unit is little more than a political illusion.
They argue that the officers who handle violent demonstrations will simply be rebranded under a new name, despite the socialist mayor's promise to disband the unit entirely. The plan targets the Strategic Response Group, known as SRG.
"The problem isday-to-day New Yorkers don't understand all this gas lighting," former NYPD Chief John Chell told Fox News Digital. "And they feel the angst of it." "But at the end of all that, this is nothing more than smoke and mirrors," Chell added.
Mamdani's plan would replace the SRG with what his office calls a "first-of-its-kind" civilian team, the Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division. The move fulfills one of his campaign promises.
The civilian unit is meant to serve as a buffer between protesters and the uniformed officers who will still be present at large demonstrations. Mamdani also announced a 30-officer NYPD unit, the First Amendment Support Team, to help calm crowds while the civilian division is developed.
Chell and retired NYPD Inspector Paul Mauro say the overhaul is a restructuring rather than a true disbandment. They believe the unit will likely be rebuilt under a different name to keep handling mass protests, major crimes and counterterrorism.
"The con here is that the SRG is simply being rebranded into an unknown name right now," Chell said. Mauro pointed to the mayor's own description of the plan. "First of all, Mamdani did addthat there will be uniformed police standing by to take more forceful enforcement if necessary," he said.
"So what really changed? Well, he changed the name of that unit and he inserted this civilian unit between those uniformed cops and the protesters," Mauro added.
Both men warned that relying on civilians to calm rowdy crowds could delay police action if a peaceful protest turns violent. That could leave officers reacting to a crisis instead of preventing it.
"Once a cop, wherever they're assigned, becomes reactive versus proactive public safety suffers," Chell said. "And [when cops] become reactive, they tend to hold back and that can get them hurt, and it can get civilians hurt."
"That is one of the risks inherent in this thing," Mauro said. "That you deploy the civilians, they're trying to talkand by the time the civilians turn around and say, 'Police, we need help,' it may be too late."
The SRG is trained to handle crowds that have turned violent, starting with verbal de-escalation. Its officers are known for using bicycles to form barricades for crowd control.
"The purpose of the SRG was to make sure that you had highly trained officers who could diffuse, spin down, but then control if need be, protests that were getting out of hand," Mauro said. "That's why they were only deployed in about 6% of the instances."
Figures cited at a city budget hearing show the NYPD handled 4,255 protests in 2025, with the SRG deployed for roughly 6% of them. Critics of the unit, including the New York Civil Liberties Union, say its counterterrorism focus leads it to "suppress protesters."
Mamdani's office did not respond to a request for comment. The mayor has not said when the civilian team will be up and running.
Chell, who has announced plans to run for mayor in 2029, doubts the new team will take shape until at least 2028, if ever. "If they get everything they want, we're gonna be a third world city and I don't know if we can ever get it back," he said.
Login