A Pennsylvania prosecutor has ruled that a fatal crossbow shooting during a family dispute was self-defense, so no one will face charges.
The case began in Sharon, a small city near the Ohio border about 60 miles north of Pittsburgh. Mercer County District Attorney Jacob Sander concluded that the single crossbow shot that killed Billy Colwell was fired in self-defense, the Youngstown television station WFMJ reported.
Sander has not disclosed the exact circumstances that led to the shooting. What is known is that Colwell was struck in the shoulder by a crossbow bolt and taken to a hospital, where he later died.
Mercer County Coroner John Libonati determined that the cause of death was a penetrating wound to the chest. The details were first reported by the Daily Caller News Foundation, whose story was republished by the Western Journal.
Police were called to the area of South Myers Avenue in the early morning hours, according to earlier WFMJ reporting cited by WKRC. Officers found Colwell critically injured from the arrow wound.
At the time, Sander confirmed that investigators were treating the death as a homicide. He said it was too early to determine whether the shooting was accidental or intentional.
The district attorney said the incident stemmed from a "domestic incident" involving a member of Colwell's family. Police told WFMJ they were speaking with a person of interest and interviewing witnesses.
Sander explained that investigators wanted to test the account they had already been given. "We know what the suspect's version of events are," he told the station. "We kind of want to get an understanding from other people who may have in or around with him earlier that evening to determine if there had been any altercations prior," Sander said.
Authorities never publicly named the person who fired the crossbow. They stressed early on that there was no danger to the wider community.
The investigation ultimately ended with the self-defense finding. Under that conclusion, the person who fired the fatal shot will not be prosecuted.
The unusual weapon has drawn attention to how common crossbows have become. In Pennsylvania, adults generally may buy and own them, and they are regulated as hunting tools by the Pennsylvania Game Commission.
Licensed hunters may use crossbows during archery seasons and certain other seasons. State rules require a minimum draw weight of 125 pounds and set specifications for the bolts fired from them.
There is no authoritative national estimate of how many Americans own crossbows. Still, at least 33 states allow their use during at least part of hunting season, according to the National Deer Association.
A 2025 study by the Archery Trade Association and Responsive Management surveyed more than 10,000 licensed bowhunters in 13 states. About 54% of respondents said they had hunted with a crossbow within the previous five years.
Those numbers suggest crossbows are now a mainstream tool, especially among experienced hunters. In Sharon, one of them became the center of a deadly family confrontation that prosecutors say was a lawful act of self-defense.
Login