New York City lawmakers want to ban restaurants from boiling live lobsters, and the city's restaurateurs are furious about it.
A bill introduced in the City Council would outlaw boiling any living crustacean, including "but not limited to lobsters and crabs." Restaurants could still serve lobster, but they would have to find another way to kill the animals before cooking them.
Under the proposal, a first violation would bring a warning. After that, each lobster boiled alive would draw a $100 fine.
The measure is sponsored by Councilmen Oswald Feliz of the Bronx and Harvey Epstein of Manhattan. Supporters argue that lobsters and other crustaceans can feel pain. "Boiling an animal alive is the textbook definition of animal cruelty," Feliz said, according to the New York Post.
Similar bans are already on the books in several countries, including Austria, Norway, New Zealand and Switzerland. Those countries suggest stunning lobsters and crabs with electricity or freezing them before killing them with a knife to the nervous system.
Restaurant owners in New York were not impressed. They say they are already buried under regulations, high rents and rising costs.
"This is nuts," said Angelo Vivolo, a retired New York Italian restaurant icon. "What's next, do they want to introduce not using cow for meat or forget about prosciutto at an Italian restaurant? Fuggadaboutit!"
"It's idiocy," Vivolo continued. "When it gets out to the restaurant industry they are going to be saying the same things. This regulation is absolutely insane."
Top Hamptons chef Zach Erdem said he would probably scrap his plans for a Manhattan restaurant if the proposal moves forward. He argued that the city has its priorities backward.
"Restaurants are fighting high rents, food costs, labor costs and taxes. Now we're supposed to worry about hurting a lobster's feelings?" Erdem said.
"What's next? Are we going to need permission from City Hall before we crack a crab leg?" he asked.
"I love New York. But when politicians start worrying more about lobsters than the people trying to make a living, something is seriously wrong," he added. "The lobsters might be safe, but the restaurant business is getting cooked!"
Critics online were quick to mock the idea. Many questioned why city leaders would focus on crustaceans at a time when New Yorkers are struggling with the cost of living.
RedState's Nick Arama called it "the hand of the nanny state," arguing that lawmakers who campaigned on affordability should not be telling people how to cook their seafood. He also pointed to other moves by Mayor Zohran Mamdani's administration, including plans for city-run grocery stores and changes to the NYPD's Strategic Response Group.
The lobster proposal is not the city's first attempt to regulate kitchens on animal welfare grounds. New York passed a ban on foie gras in 2019, but that measure has been tied up in legal challenges for years.
It is not yet clear whether the lobster bill has enough support to pass the City Council. For now, restaurateurs are making it clear they intend to fight it.
Login