A prominent conservative legal team is urging Ohio lawmakers to make sure no foreign or religious ruling can strip residents of their constitutional rights.
The civil and religious rights attorneys at the American Center for Law and Justice have submitted testimony backing Ohio Senate Bill 380, WND reported. The measure would shield residents "from foreign laws, judgments, decrees, and agreements that violate rights secured by the U.S. Constitution, the Ohio Constitution, federal law, or Ohio's fundamental public policy."
The bill, sponsored by Republican state Sen. Terry Johnson, sits in the Senate Government Oversight and Reform Committee. It would direct state and local government bodies not to recognize or enforce any foreign law or religious rule that conflicts with rights guaranteed under the U.S. and Ohio constitutions.
The bill text lists specific practices that could not be given legal effect, including discrimination against women, forced marriage, plural marriage, restrictions on leaving a religion and female genital mutilation. Supporters say the protections are aimed squarely at abuses, not at any one faith.
The ACLJ framed the issue around Sharia-based divorces that have surfaced in American courtrooms. "The problem is real. Courts in Ohio and around the country have confronted foreign divorces obtained without notice, unilateral procedures available only to husbands, and decrees threatening a spouse's rights to property or support," the group said.
One example came out of Ohio itself. A husband tried to use a Sudanese divorce certificate against his wife, who had never been served with the paperwork, and the state's Fifth District appeals court refused to recognize it.
The ACLJ asked readers to put themselves in that position. "Imagine discovering that your spouse divorced you in another country without your knowledge, without serving you with legal papers, and without ever giving you a chance to be heard. Then imagine being told that an American court should simply accept that divorce and give it legal effect here," the group wrote.
That scenario is not hypothetical, the ACLJ said, because "American courts are being confronted with divorce cases based on Sharia law and that raises these precise concerns." Its core argument is that the U.S. Constitution and American legal principles must take precedence over Sharia or any other religious code.
"These cases expose the fundamental distinction at the heart of S.B. 380. Religious liberty does not require an American court to use the coercive power of government to enforce a religious or foreign legal result that violates another person's constitutional rights," the group said.
The ACLJ stressed that the bill does not single out Islam or any particular country. The same rule would apply whether a dispute arises under Sharia, Hindu law, another religious tradition or a secular foreign legal system, and the group noted that American courts have already refused to enforce English libel judgments that clashed with free speech protections.
The group argued that the current system forces victims to fight piecemeal. "Some courts already reach the right result. But currently Ohioans must fight the same battle case by case," the ACLJ said.
"And challenging a foreign decree can be burdensome, requiring a vulnerable party to hire counsel, prove inadequate notice or procedures, establish the governing foreign law, and sometimes pursue an appeal simply to preserve rights American law already guarantees," the group continued. "S.B. 380 provides a clear rule from the outset."
The ACLJ closed with a defense of both religious freedom and constitutional limits. "American law properly respects foreign judgments and strongly protects religious liberty. But neither principle requires surrendering constitutional rights," the group said.
"A foreign government, religious tribunal, or private agreement should never be able to accomplish through an Ohio court what Ohio itself could not constitutionally do," the ACLJ wrote. The bill remains in committee awaiting further action.
Login