How Did A Convicted Child Abuser Get A Texas Court To Bless His Surrogacy Deal?The Paperwork Tells The Story

Written by Published

A 76-year-old man convicted of abusing young boys paid a Texas surrogate to carry a baby boy he planned to raise alone, court records show.

Sanford S. Kaplan, a former geologist who lives in Colorado, signed a surrogacy agreement with a young Texas woman in February 2025, according to Travis County court documents first obtained by The Federalist. The child was conceived using Kaplan's sperm and a donor egg.

Under the deal, the baby would go into Kaplan's sole and "immediate custody" after birth. According to court testimony, Kaplan was given the chance to choose the child's sex and picked a boy.

The surrogate, identified only by the initials S.M., was paid about $50,000. The agreement named Kaplan as "the legal father," the filing said.

What the surrogate says she was never told is that Kaplan had abused multiple boys between the ages of 10 and 15 at his Nebraska home. The abuse ran from the 1990s until 2009, while he was serving as a youth soccer coach.

Victims testified that he blindfolded, bound and gagged them and suspended them from the rafters of his garage, the Lincoln Journal Star reported at the time. They said he photographed them as they struggled to get free.

Kaplan pleaded no contest in 2009 to seven counts of child abuse and one count of false imprisonment. He was sentenced to 24 years in prison but served about seven, finished parole in 2021 and was ordered to register as a sex offender.

Two years later, a judge ruled he did not have to stay on the registry because his convictions were not for crimes sexual in nature. A search of the Colorado and national registries for Kaplan turned up no results, according to the Daily Mail.

Texas law required a home study to determine whether the intended parent's home was safe for a child. That step never happened, because Kaplan and the surrogate filed a joint petition asking the court to approve the agreement without it, and the court signed off.

The plan unraveled just days before the birth. Staff at Baylor Scott & White Medical CenterLake Pointe in Rockwall County intervened, and the Texas Department of Family and Protective Services stepped in.

The agency stopped Kaplan from taking the newborn home. In an affidavit supporting the child's removal, DFPS said Kaplan admitted to more victims than the courts ever knew about.

"When asked if there were other children not identified in previous child abuse allegations, [Kaplan] confirmed that there were additional victims, estimating a total of 17 or 18," the affidavit said. "Mr. Kaplan described actions including holding some children, suspending them, and blindfolding some of them before engaging in sexual acts."

The surrogate told authorities Kaplan never disclosed his criminal history. She said she wanted "nothing to do with the child or the situation" and did not want "any backlash."

Even Kaplan's own surrogacy attorney turned on him. In a filing withdrawing from the case, the lawyer wrote that Kaplan "misrepresented his criminal history to myself and to the court."

A Baylor Scott & White executive also testified that Kaplan had signed a declaration saying he had "never been convicted of a felony or a crime involving moral turpitude." A Travis County jury later terminated his parental rights, finding that his conduct and convictions endangered the child.

The boy is now in foster care in the custody of DFPS and has "documented medical needs." Kaplan has filed an appeal and is still fighting for custody.

At trial, Kaplan insisted he was a "changed man." He said much the same thing in Nebraska years ago, telling the judge at sentencing, "I want to sincerely express my remorse for what I have done."