A wealthy son is paying protesters to picket Saks Fifth Avenue after his mother was beaten by a customer and then fired by the store.
Jeffrey Vinokur, 36, sold his company Generation Genius for $100 million last year. He has now hired 15 protesters to picket the flagship Manhattan store seven days a week, and he says they will stay until Saks' leadership publicly apologizes and backs changes to New York's employment laws.
Vinokur told the New York Post he has already spent $12,600 to pay the protesters for seven days. He has since expanded the protest to sister store Bergdorf Goodman, adding another $1,800 a day to his bill.
He vowed to fund the protests indefinitely, right through the holiday season. That includes Saks' famous Holiday Light Show and Bergdorf's holiday window unveiling, two of the busiest and most photographed events on Fifth Avenue.
His 62-year-old mother, who does not want to be identified, had been working in the store's fifth-floor ready-to-wear department for just two weeks. She said the trouble began in June when a customer asked where to find the Casablanca brand.
She said she asked the customer about the price point so she could take her to the right section, and the woman became enraged. The customer demanded that a manager fire her on the spot, then followed her into a dressing room area where the manager had told her to wait.
In the dressing room, the customer "pulled out her phone with a straight arm in my face and started filming me or taking pictures asking 'what's your last name,'" the mother said. She responded by pulling out her own phone and recording the customer as she left with her two children.
According to the police report, the customer turned around and returned, hitting the mother "with a closed fist and kick(ing) her in the stomach." The mother described the attack in vivid terms.
"She started punching me, kicking me multiple times, grabbed my glasses," she said. "She was like an animal. Three or four co-workers started to pull her off of me just as I was about to fall."
She said store security told her police had been called, but nearly 30 minutes passed with no officers. She called them herself and then called her son, who rushed to the store and found her with an ice bag on her head.
She was taken to a hospital by ambulance. The customer was arrested, charged with assault and aggravated harassment, and pleaded guilty, according to police records.
Five days after the attack, Saks fired the mother by email and a FedExed letter. The company said it had tried to reach her by phone but she did not return its calls.
"This decision is the result of serious policy violations and insubordinate behavior," the letter said. It cited the video she took and accused her of "refusing to comply with directions from your manager."
"Your lack of judgment and inappropriate conduct directly escalated a situation with a customer and resulted in a physical altercation, and endangered the safety of yourself and others," the letter continued. The family says Saks never explained how she disobeyed her manager.
Saks defended its record in a statement, saying, "We take matters of employee and customer safety and security extremely seriously." The company added, "It is the company's firmly held policy that we do not retaliate against any employee who reports violations of our policies or the law. All reports are investigated promptly and thoroughly."
Vinokur said he looked into suing but learned New York lacks protections that some states, including California, Illinois and Vermont, give to victims of violent crime. "If you are a victim of a violent crime and you have a police report, you can't be fired in several other states, but New York is not one of them," he said.
Employment attorney Darren Oved cautioned that such laws might not have helped. "It's very jarring that she gets fired after this and it does look like how could you do this to this poor lady," Oved said, but he added that Saks has "the right to fire someone if you are not following their policy."
Vinokur claims his mother is the seventh Saks employee fired after reporting harassment or assault, citing six other cases he found in court records. Five of those cases were settled, and a sixth was affected by Saks' bankruptcy this year.
The protesters, supplied by a staffing agency, earn $20 an hour for six-hour shifts. One sign reads "Raped at Saks," a reference to a 1994 case in which a Saks security guard pleaded guilty to sexually assaulting a company executive.
Other signs read "Beaten at Saks. Then Fired" and "She called 911. Saks fired her."
Vinokur, who also built a website featuring court documents from the other cases, wants an apology from Geoffroy van Raemdonck, who leads Saks' parent company, along with an investigation of all the attacks and the firing of those responsible. "We are going to be here every day until we get what we want," he said.
Login