Democratic Party Leader In Pennsylvania Exposed As Noncitizen After 40 Years In Power

Written by Published

A man who spent decades atop Pennsylvania Democratic politics has been forced to leave the country after learning he was never a U.S. citizen.

Ian Murray, 75, chaired the Erie County Democratic Party and sat on the Democratic National Committee for 30 years. According to reporting by the Erie Times-News, highlighted by Gateway Pundit, he has now moved to Nova Scotia in his native Canada.

Murray was born in Canada in 1951 and moved to Erie with his family in 1956, when he was 5 years old. He lived in the United States for roughly 70 years, mostly in Erie, and had long believed he was an American.

That belief unraveled when he applied for a U.S. passport. The application prompted a review of his mother's residency history, and the answer came from a law passed before he was even born.

Under the Nationality Act of 1940, a child born abroad to one American parent and one non-citizen parent could only inherit citizenship if the American parent had lived in the United States for a total of 10 years before the birth. According to the State Department, at least five of those years had to come after the parent's 16th birthday.

Murray's mother, a dual citizen, fell just short of that requirement. Federal officials concluded that her son had never acquired citizenship at birth.

The Department of Homeland Security then issued him a Notice to Appear in immigration court. The notice described Murray as "an alien present in the United States who has not been admitted or paroled."

It identified him as "a native of Canada and a citizen of Canada" and "not a citizen or national of the United States." An immigration judge later granted Murray voluntary departure, which allowed him to leave on his own rather than face a formal removal order.

Murray told the Erie Times-News he chose to leave in order to avoid a costly legal fight. "I can't believe this is happening," he said.

He had already retired from law and politics several years ago and was living in Maine when the case began. He left for Canada from there.

His political rsum is long. Murray became chairman of the Erie County Democratic Party in 1986 and led it until 1998, and by his own account he was the youngest county chair in the state.

He was elected to the Democratic National Committee in 1992 and later described himself as the longest-serving DNC member in Pennsylvania history. He also sat on the Pennsylvania State Democratic Committee from 1986 until he stepped away from politics in 2022.

Murray served on Erie City Council, worked as an assistant public defender and built a long career as a defense attorney. He chaired the Erie City Human Relations Commission in the 1970s and served on the boards of several local civic organizations.

Federal law bars noncitizens from voting in federal elections. Pennsylvania also requires anyone registering to vote to attest, under penalty of law, that they are a U.S. citizen.

Nothing in the reporting suggests Murray knew about the problem. By his account, he believed he was a citizen until the passport review said otherwise.

Still, the case raises an uncomfortable question for a party that has spent years dismissing concerns about citizenship checks. A man who helped run Democratic politics in a key swing state for decades was never legally eligible for the citizenship his roles assumed, and no one noticed until he tried to get a passport.