Two undercover journalists walked into a Minneapolis courthouse to fight felony charges, and what happened outside has become a story of its own.
James O'Keefe and Cam Higby appeared in Hennepin County court this week on charges of unlawful voting and identity theft. The charges stem from an undercover operation in which the pair posed as Muslims to show how Minnesota's "vouching" system works.
Under that system, a registered voter can vouch for up to eight unregistered people in the same precinct, allowing them to vote. O'Keefe and Higby say their goal was to expose what they called the "sheer lunacy" of the rule, according to Courthouse News.
Getting into the building turned into an ordeal. Video posted to social media showed the two men pushing through a crowd of protesters, supporters and media outside the Hennepin County Public Safety Facility.
"It was shocking to me how there was no police presence outside the courthouse in Minneapolis," O'Keefe said afterward. "It is unconscionable and a danger to the witnesses walking in, as well as public safety."
"People were assaulted by the mob including an @OKeefeMedia correspondent. They know when and where we'll be so they know exactly when they take a shot at us," he continued. "How can the justice system work under violent mob rule?"
Higby described a similar scene. "As I walked into the courtroom, I watched several assaults. This just follows Minnesota's pattern of failing to deal with real criminals and prosecuting political dissent," he said.
Higby added that the pair had planned to hold a news conference after the hearing, but their security team and deputies "determined that it wasn't safe for us to walk out the front doors." "Our walk into the courthouse was a shoving match. Protestors ran right at us, threatened us and displayed weapons before we arrived," he said.
O'Keefe said sheriffs escorted the group through the skyway because of the crowd. "This is retaliation for journalism, plain and simple. The truth shall set me free," he said.
His attorney, Chris Madel, accused Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty of targeting his client. "The only reason that James O'Keefe is getting charged in this case is because Mary Moriarty disagrees with him," Madel said, calling it "a political prosecution."
"James O'Keefe is the true victim here and we're going to show his innocence," he added. First Amendment litigator Benjamin Barr said, "This is what happens when the powerful fear an independent and free press. They turn questioning the powerful into felonies."
Inside, the hearing lasted roughly 10 minutes, according to Alpha News. Hennepin County Judge Luis Bartolomei released both men without bail, on the condition that they have no contact with victims or election judges named in the charging documents.
Prosecutors failed in their bid to also bar the two defendants from contacting each other. "There's just absolutely no reason for that other than to try to interfere with the defense," Madel said.
Prosecutors allege the pair visited several precincts during this summer's primary and gave poll workers the names of registered voters, some of them deceased, without permission. The men never signed the voter oath, but Moriarty has argued that misrepresenting yourself to get a ballot is still a crime.
"The fundamental issue here is that you cannot go into a polling place and misidentify yourself and use other people's identities to our election judges as you apply for a ballot, whether or not you intend to vote," Moriarty said, according to WND. Minnesota Secretary of State Steve Simon said, "Any attempt to disrupt or deceive our election workers will not be tolerated."
O'Keefe has said his team trained participants never to sign an affidavit or touch a ballot, and neither man was given one, according to a report published by The Seattle Times. Higby's attorney, Ryan Garry, told Alpha News the pair won't take a plea deal and will file a motion to dismiss. State officials say fewer than 0.6% of votes in the 2024 general election were cast using vouching.
Even some legal experts see room for a defense. "If they're persuaded that the conduct was not intended to cause the harm that law prohibits, false voting, but it was actually to uncover a flaw in the system, it would be within their discretion to acquit them," University of Minnesota professor emerita Jane Kirtley told WCCO-TV. O'Keefe and Higby are due back in court in January.
Login