The Democrat trying to unseat Pennsylvania's John Fetterman got a simple yes-or-no question on national television, and three tries later, there was still no answer.
Ahmed Moor, a Gaza-born writer and member of the Democratic Socialists of America, has launched a 2028 primary challenge against Fetterman (D-PA). Fetterman has already fired back, calling Moor "pro-Hamas."
"This is someone that is very proud, very proud, pro-Hamas, and there are parts of my Democratic base [that] find my views more troubling or offensive, my strong support of Israel versus his views," Fetterman said in a recent Fox News interview. "I'm always going to support Israel," he added.
So when Moor sat down with Fox News anchor Martha MacCallum, she put the senator's charge to him directly. "John Fetterman, who you may run against, says that you are very pro-Hamas. Is he correct?" she asked.
"Look, John Fetterman's story's over," Moor replied, insisting the bigger story was "the Democratic mandate." MacCallum didn't let it go, pressing, "I'm asking you a question," before asking again, "Are you very pro-Hamas?"
Moor repeated the question back before pivoting to Israel. "Am I pro-Hamas? I'd like to see equal rights in Palestine and Israel," he said.
"I'm opposed to Israeli apartheid. I'd like to see comprehensive sanctions on Israel, in line with legislation that we passed in 1986 targeting apartheid in South Africa," Moor continued. He then invoked Thomas Jefferson's words that "all men are created equal," adding, "As an American, I defy anybody to tell me no."
MacCallum tried a third time, noting that poverty in Gaza had been about 35 percent when Hamas took over and has since climbed into the 60s. "So my question once again, if you would just answer it: are you pro-Hamas leadership in Gaza?" she asked.
Moor answered by recounting his own story. "Look, I was born in a refugee camp, practically a concentration camp, in Palestine, in Gaza, in 1984. Hamas didn't exist in 1984," he said.
He went on to blame what he called "the Israeli occupation" for the region's suffering. "The Israelis have too much influence in our foreign policy. The fact that Benjamin Netanyahu and Donald Trump took us to war in Iran, when most Americans, the overwhelming majority of the country, opposed that war, is a problem," Moor said.
MacCallum called out the dodge. "I've now asked you three times and you won't answer my question," she said, pointing to the October 7 attack on Israel and calling it "a vicious attack."
"It's a bad faith question," Moor shot back. "I'm not going to engage with that. I'm going to focus on the American national interest."
"I think we need an independent foreign policy. Americans on left and right are done with Israel," he said. "We're done with the tail wagging the dog."
Moor's campaign has rejected Fetterman's label, saying he condemns violence against civilians and supports an arms embargo and targeted sanctions on Israel, Anadolu Agency reported. Moor, 42, told the outlet he wants "full equal rights for Palestinians and Jewish Israelis in a democracy."
Conservative commentators were not persuaded. Writing for Hot Air, Ed Morrissey noted that Israel withdrew from Gaza in 2005, years before Hamas seized power there, and argued that Moor's history lesson conveniently skipped that part.
Fetterman, who has drawn criticism from fellow Democrats over his outspoken support for Israel, has not said whether he will seek reelection. If he does, Moor's interview suggests the Israel fight will be front and center.
Login