Ana Navarro condemned efforts to recast convicted murderer Christa Pike as a victim after Tennessees failed attempt to execute her, insisting public sympathy belongs with the young woman Pike tortured and killed and with that victims grieving mother.
The tense exchange unfolded on Fridays edition of The View, where the co-hosts largely agreed that the focus should remain on Pikes victim, not on the condemned killers suffering, as reported by Mediaite. Moderator Whoopi Goldberg opened the segment by deliberately naming 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer, Pikes classmate, whose brutal death has been overshadowed in some media coverage by the botched execution. Slemmers mother, May Martinez, had traveled to Nashville to witness the execution of Pike, now 50, only to see the process halted after the state failed to carry it out.
Pike was 18 when she and two other teenagers, including her 17-year-old boyfriend, lured Slemmer to a remote area and subjected her to a sadistic attack. The group tortured Slemmer, carved a pentagram into her chest, and crushed her skull, a crime so vicious it shocked even seasoned law enforcement officers at the time.
Despite defense arguments that Pike was herself a child rape victim who grew up in an abusive environment, a jury convicted her of first-degree murder in 1996. She was subsequently sentenced to death, becoming the youngest woman on death row in the United States, a status that has drawn renewed attention from anti-death penalty activists.
Goldberg, while not dismissing concerns about the states competence in carrying out executions, stressed that the moral center of the story remains with Slemmers family. Me personally, I think you should ask the mother what should happen now. I think they should ask her because, you know, they tortured her daughter and theres a reason she was where she was, but I think its, its not a question that the state should answer, Goldberg said on Friday.
Navarro, often one of the more outspoken voices on the panel, said she fully agreed that Slemmers family should guide any discussion about what happens next in Pikes case. She then sharply criticized the narrative shift that has cast Pike as a figure of pity rather than as a brutal killer, venting her frustration at what she sees as a media and activist tendency to forget the real victim.
I fully agree with you and Im glad that every time we have talked about this you have led with mentioning the true victims name, Colleen Slemmer, and her mother, May Martinez, because, you know, this is just driving me crazy, Navarro said, underscoring the importance of centering the victim rather than the perpetrator. It feels like all of a sudden the woman who tortured the 18-year-old and killed the 18-year-old girl has now become the victim.
Navarro went on to fault the state for its failure to competently administer justice after more than three decades, but she reserved her strongest criticism for the cultural impulse to empathize with the killer over the slain teenager. I am outraged at the state that couldnt get this one thing right after 31 years, that has made this family that has suffered so muchthe worst loss that you could possibly suffer, has waited for over three decades, and now have to go through this and see the assassin, the convicted killer, treated as if she was the victim in this case, she said. So Im with you. I think the victims family needs to lead.
Co-host Sunny Hostin offered a limited dissent, reiterating her opposition to capital punishment on religious grounds while still acknowledging the horror of Pikes crime. Hostin argued that a life sentence without parole would be a more appropriate punishment, aligning with the Catholic Churchs increasingly firm stance against the death penalty.
While what she did is horribly heinous, her boyfriend that was 17 at the time is in prison for the rest of his life and I think life imprisonment would be appropriate right now at this time, Hostin said, suggesting that Pikes punishment should mirror that of her co-defendant. Her position highlighted a familiar divide: whether justice is better served by the ultimate penalty or by ensuring a killer spends the rest of her life behind bars.
Meanwhile, Pikes legal team is pressing the courts to scrutinize the failed execution and its aftermath, raising questions about her current physical condition and the states next steps. Randy Spivey, one of Pikes attorneys, said this week that she is conscious but disoriented following the aborted lethal injection, during which she was given two doses of pentobarbital.
She cannot move either of her arms, both of her arms and hands are tremendously swollen, and we do not know what, if any, function she will regain in her arms. But we do know that there is a long road ahead, Spivey said, describing his clients condition as the legal battle continues. A judge has ordered that evidence related to the execution attempt be preserved, leaving Tennessee officials to decide whether to try again, even as many Americansparticularly those on the rightinsist that the states first obligation is to honor the memory of Colleen Slemmer and the decades-long anguish of her mother, not to elevate the suffering of a convicted murderer.
Login