Greg Gutfeld clashed sharply with liberal co-host Jessica Tarlov on Fox News The Five this week over her portrayal of the fatal shooting of Alex Pretti by ICE agents.
According to Gateway Pundit, Tarlov repeated a familiar left-wing narrative, claiming Pretti was murdered by ICE while omitting key facts about his behavior and the threat he posed. The segment marked the return of the kind of pointed GutfeldTarlov exchange that has long highlighted the ideological divide on the show, with Gutfeld openly challenging what he framed as a dishonest and incomplete account of the incident.
Tarlov began by invoking a sympathetic media framing, noting that Alex Prettis family were interviewed by George Stephanopoulos, and theyre talking about their son, sibling being murdered by ICE and that there has been no accountability for that. She added, And that is a tragedy and something that also changed course in the way that ICE was allowed to operate.
Gutfeld immediately cut in, pointing out that the narrative shifted once the full evidence emerged. Until we saw the tape, Gutfeld interrupted her. Then we realized that he was agitating, kicking.
Tarlov reacted with an exasperated Oh my God, but Gutfeld pressed the point, emphasizing the danger posed to law enforcement. Didnt he kick the a guy comes and attacks your car and hes holding a gun. What is a cop supposed to do? Im just giving you the facts. You did not mention the facts of the story. I had to put in there. I am your AI. Your Grok, Gutfeld said.
Shifting ground, Tarlov then invoked another left-wing touchstone, the death of George Floyd, in an attempt to undermine Gutfelds argument. And I heard from you last week that George Floyd would be bopping around no problem, that he overdosed instead of the fact that Derek Chauvin had his knee on his neck, Tarlov continued.
Gutfeld did not retreat, reiterating his view that drugs played a decisive role in Floyds death. He overdosed. He also overdosed a few weeks before. He was in intensive care, Gutfeld replied. Yeah, call me Grok 2.2.
Co-host Kennedy punctured the sanctification of Floyd that dominates progressive discourse, quipping, He was a saint, in a pointed jab at the lefts canonization of deeply flawed figures. For conservatives, the exchange underscored a broader pattern: activists and liberal media figures weaponizing tragic cases like Prettis not to seek truth or accountability, but to smear ICE, undermine law enforcement, and advance an anti-police, anti-border agenda.
The lefts outrage machine rarely acknowledges that officers face split-second life-or-death decisions when confronted by an armed suspect attacking a vehicle, yet it is precisely those facts Gutfeld insisted on restoring to the conversation. In calling out Tarlovs omissions, he highlighted a central conservative concern: that selective storytelling and emotional manipulation are being used to erode support for the men and women tasked with enforcing the law and securing the border.
Login