Donald Trump, still bristling at the Supreme Courts June ruling on birthright citizenship, has moved aggressively to reassert executive authority over who can claim automatic American citizenship and how.
According to RedState, the president reacted swiftly after the Court struck down his earlier executive order limiting birthright citizenship, calling the decision too bad for our country in a social media post. Rather than accept the setback, the Department of Justice promptly issued a department-wide memorandum instructing federal prosecutors to prioritize investigations and prosecutions of individuals and networks attempting to exploit the citizenship system through fraud.
Trump escalated his response by signing two new executive orders aimed squarely at tightening the rules surrounding birthright citizenship and shutting down what critics have long described as a cottage industry of abuse. The first order formally delineates categories of foreign nationals whose children will not be eligible for birthright citizenship, while the second targets the phenomenon known as birth tourism, in which foreign mothers enter the United States under false pretenses to secure U.S. citizenship for their newborns.
At the Oval Office signing ceremony, Trump framed the actions as a matter of basic fairness and national integrity. "We're making adjustments because it's very unfair," he said, adding, "They're building businesses around birthright citizenship. That's not the way it was supposed to work. It's a disgrace.
The White House emphasized that these moves are a direct response to the Supreme Courts decision in Trump v. Barbara, which limited the administrations earlier attempt to curb automatic citizenship. @POTUS underscored the point: "We had a very unfortunate decision in the Supreme Court concerning birthright [citizenship]... so we're making adjustments."
According to the administrations description, the first executive order non-exhaustively identifies certain categories of children of aliens who are not entitled to birthright citizenship consistent with historical exceptions to birthright citizenship recognized by the Supreme Court in Barbara. These categories include, for example, alien enemies of the United States, members of foreign terrorist organizations, and large categories of people who lobby and act on behalf of foreign governments, as Trump aide Stephen Miller later explained.
The second order delegates presidential authorities to the Secretary of State and Secretary of Homeland Security and directs them to halt the practice of birth tourism. In practical terms, that means consular officers and immigration authorities will be instructed to scrutinize visa applications and travel patterns more closely, with the explicit aim of stopping those who enter the country under the guise of tourism but intend to give birth on U.S. soil.
White House Deputy Chief of Staff for Policy Stephen Miller made clear that the administration views this as a decisive break with past laxity. That practice of birth tourism is, as of this signing of this order, hereby banned," he declared, describing the move as a long-overdue correction to a system that has been gamed by foreign nationals and, in some cases, organized criminal enterprises.
Miller elaborated on the broader significance of the first order, stressing that Trump is using his authority as commander in chief to sign first an executive order, using the new ruling the Supreme Court issued, to expand the definitions of people who are ineligible for birthright citizenship. From a conservative standpoint, the idea that terrorists and alien enemies could ever have been in a gray area regarding their childrens citizenship underscores how far the legal and bureaucratic status quo had drifted from common sense.
He then turned to what he called the especially historic second action. "The second action that he's taking, which is especially historic, is for the first time ever, in American history, to ban birth tourism The idea that people come here, pretending to be a tourist, pretending to be a visitor, saying they want to go to Disneyland But the real reason they're here is to have a child, to make that child with an automatic citizen, leave our country, and then have a U.S. citizen child. So, that practice of birth tourism is, as of the signing of this order, hereby banned."
Miller placed these orders among Trumps most consequential immigration measures, alongside his reversal of Joe Bidens permissive border posture and efforts to restore enforcement at the southern frontier. It ends what has been one of the gravest and most egregious abuses of the American system, he added, capturing a view widely shared on the right that citizenship should not be a commodity to be purchased through visa fraud or legal loopholes.
As with nearly every major Trump immigration initiative, legal challenges are all but certain, with critics likely to argue that the orders exceed executive authority or conflict with existing interpretations of the Fourteenth Amendment. No word yet on whether Judge James Boasberg is already exploring ways to block the EOs, but conservatives will be watching closely to see whether the judiciary once again steps in to shield a status quo that has long favored loopholes and lawfare over the clear, sovereign control of American citizenship.
Login