Newly obtained federal documents suggest the Obama administration may have missed a critical opportunity to take confessed killer Joran van der Sloot off the streets before he claimed a second victim.
According to Western Journal, veteran journalist and Newsmax host Greta Van Susteren says she has secured internal FBI records and video that indicate the bureau bungled a 2010 sting operation targeting Van der Sloot and then kept it quiet from the American public. Van Susteren, an award-winning legal analyst, obtained the material through a Freedom of Information Act request, aided by former Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi, and says the documents were ultimately released to her by the Department of Justice under President Donald Trump.
Van Susteren has announced plans to publish both the FBI files and the video of the sting, raising fresh questions about how the Obama-era Justice Department handled a suspect already linked to the disappearance of Alabama teenager Natalee Holloway. She first revealed the existence of the material in a Facebook post, signaling that the public would soon be able to see for itself how federal agents conducted the operation.
The records, released to her by Trumps DOJ, reportedly show that the Obama FBI failed to arrest Van der Sloot in 2010 despite having him in their sights in connection with Holloways case. Instead, the bureau allegedly allowed him to walk away from a sting that unfolded just weeks before he murdered 21-year-old Peruvian student Stephany Flores Ramrez.
Twenty days before Ramrez was killed on May 30, 2010, an intermediary working with the FBI delivered an initial $25,000 of a promised $250,000 to Van der Sloot $10,000 in cash, $15,000 wired in exchange for information on the location of Holloways remains, according to NPR. The information Van der Sloot provided turned out to be false, yet federal authorities did not immediately move to detain him.
Instead, the Obama Justice Department, then led by Attorney General Eric Holder, waited until June 3, 2010, to file extortion and wire-fraud charges against Van der Sloot. By that time, Ramrez had already been murdered in Lima, a crime for which he would later be convicted in Peru.
For years, critics have argued that the FBI under President Barack Obama had both the leverage and the obligation to arrest Van der Sloot the moment he took the money and lied about Holloways remains. From a law-and-order perspective, the episode has been cited as a textbook example of federal hesitation and bureaucratic caution overriding the imperative to protect innocent life.
Van Susteren has said it is not yet fully clear what every page and frame of the material will reveal, but she has hinted at deeply troubling details. In her Facebook post, she wrote that some of the FBI documents are handwritten and refer to Holder warning them not to screw it up, adding that the real question is, Screw what up? Reportedly the cover up.
In a separate post on X, formerly Twitter, Van Susteren emphasized that obtaining the records was a lengthy battle with the federal bureaucracy. Her comments underscore how difficult it can be, even for a high-profile journalist, to pry loose information from agencies that often default to secrecy when their own conduct is at issue.
Holloway, an 18-year-old high school graduate from Alabama, vanished on May 30, 2005, while on a post-graduation trip to Aruba with classmates. She was last seen in the early morning hours leaving a popular nightclub in the company of Van der Sloot, then 17, and two brothers, Deepak and Satish Kalpoe.
Aruban authorities mounted an extensive investigation and detained Van der Sloot and the Kalpoe brothers on suspicion of involvement in Holloways disappearance and presumed murder. However, they ultimately released all three, saying they lacked sufficient evidence to bring formal charges that would stand up in court.
By late 2007, prosecutors in Aruba closed the case against the trio without filing any indictments, leaving Holloways family without answers. Her body has never been recovered, and at her fathers request, an Alabama court issued a legal declaration of death in early 2012, according to CNN.
Van der Sloot was eventually convicted in Peru in 2012 for the murder of Ramrez and sentenced to 28 years in a Peruvian prison. His record behind bars has been anything but clean; in 2023, he received an additional 18-year sentence for trafficking drugs while incarcerated.
Also in 2023, Van der Sloot pleaded guilty in the United States to the extortion and wire-fraud charges first filed by the Obama administration more than a decade earlier. As part of that plea deal, he claimed to finally reveal the truth about Holloway, telling authorities that he had bludgeoned her with a cinder block on an Aruba beach and dumped her body into the ocean.
Van Susteren has publicly challenged that account, arguing that Van der Sloots supposed confession does not square with the evidence and may itself be another manipulation. Susteren recently alleged that this admission from Van der Sloot was a lie, raising the possibility that federal prosecutors accepted a false narrative in exchange for closing a politically sensitive file.
Despite his various admissions and the long-standing suspicion surrounding him, Van der Sloot has never been charged with or convicted of Holloways murder. The emerging picture of a dangerous predator left free due to prosecutorial delay and an FBI sting that appears to have been mishandled at the highest levels will likely fuel renewed scrutiny of the Obama-era Justice Department and its priorities, especially among Americans who believe government should be transparent, accountable, and unwavering in its duty to protect the innocent.
Login