Two Sacramento officials were caught on a hot mic appearing to strategize about how to bar unruly residents from future city council meetings, reinforcing growing concerns that some California leaders would rather mute dissent than listen to it.
The exchange unfolded Tuesday after a raucous public outcry over an agreement between the city and the Central California Intelligence Center, a federally funded information-sharing hub that works with US Immigration and Customs Enforcement, according to The New York Post. Audience members, many of them furious over cooperation with federal immigration enforcement, berated the council and specifically targeted Vice Mayor Karina Talamantes before a half-hour recess was called to restore order.
Youre a pick-me bitch, one attendee shouted at Talamantes after she spoke, while others yelled, Shame on you. Shame on you.
The tense atmosphere set the stage for what came next, when the microphones captured a candid conversation between Talamantes and Mayor Kevin McCarty during the break.
As the council paused proceedings, Talamantes walked over to McCarty and leaned in to discuss how to deal with vocal critics in the chamber. We should go over this disruptions thing, because if we want to ban somebody in the future, like to take them out, we have to point out specifically she said, trailing off as she spoke quietly.
McCarty responded by insisting that the citys legal advisers had already shut down that approach. I know, but the city attorney said we cant do that, he replied, prompting Talamantes to counter, We did it last time.
We cant, McCarty insisted, shaking his head and recalling his earlier efforts to clamp down on disruptive residents. I spent my first six months going over this. I wanted to give people, like, probation, like, you cant come he continued, before a visibly alarmed Talamantes lunged to switch off the microphone, finished the conversation off-air, and returned to her seat.
Both officials later declined to fully explain the hot-mic remarks when questioned by The Sacramento Bee, but they framed their discussion as an attempt to maintain order rather than stifle speech.
Talamantes said, My goal is to ensure everyone gets the opportunity to address the mayor and council in a productive way, while also denouncing the uglier side of the backlash.
Threatening members of the community and elected officials family members is unacceptable in the democracy we are fighting for, she added, casting herself as a defender of civil discourse even as critics accused her of trying to muzzle them. McCarty, for his part, said the conversation was prompted by repeated interruptions that he claimed were undermining the councils work.
Following repeated audience disruptions that interfered with the councils ability to conduct its business, Vice Mayor Talamantes and I discussed existing policies and rules to ensure Council meetings remain effective, orderly, and respectful for both the residents in attendance and the Councilmembers, he wrote in a statement.
Yet for many residents, the incident only confirmed their suspicion that city leaders are more interested in controlling the public than being accountable to it.
One of the most outspoken critics, resident Leanna Hunt, has repeatedly clashed with McCarty and made no effort to soften her language. In a previous meeting, she called him a goddamn criminal, and on another occasion erupted, McCarty Im fking talking to you. Kevin! Shame on you, you fking criminal.
Hunt said her anger is not a calculated stunt but the product of years of feeling ignored by officials who treat citizens as subjects rather than stakeholders. Im fed up, she said, likening the councils behavior to feudal arrogance: Its not even a tactic Im just tired of being treated like we are an audience and that the king is deigning to see us peasants today and when the peasants are unruly, the king gets upset.
Joshua Masias, a volunteer organizer with the Sac Immigration Committee, told The Sacramento Bee that the hot-mic moment exposed Talamantes as particularly eager to shut down dissent.
Its very authoritative how she wants to use her power, Masias said, adding, It stuck out to me that she was the only one to try to silence the crowd.
For critics of Californias increasingly heavy-handed progressive governance, the episode underscores a broader pattern: officials champion democracy and inclusion while exploring ways to exclude the very people who challenge them. As residents continue to protest the citys cooperation with a federal intelligence center and ICE, the question now is whether Sacramentos leaders will tolerate robust even uncomfortable public scrutiny, or keep looking for new ways to sideline the voices they find inconvenient.
Login