Socialist New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is facing criticism after using the official New York City Mayor X account to promote Islamic religious observances tied to Ramadan and Eid.
According to The Post Millennial, Mamdani posted a video message on the mayoral account marking the end of Ramadan, captioned, "Eid Mubarak, New York," and directing viewers to a longer YouTube video hosted on the official New York City Mayor's Office channel. In the video, Mamdani speaks at length about the spiritual meaning of the holiday, using explicitly religious language and reflections that many argue cross the line between personal faith and public office.
Mamdani recounted remarks from a recent city hall iftar, saying, "There was something that someone said at an iftar that we just hosted at city hall the other night, which really stayed with me, though, is how Ramadan is also a lesson in the shallowness of instant gratification, of how you spend all day craving food and craving water and anything you could fill yourself with, and then as soon as you break your fast, just a few minutes into eating, will already feel full, and it's as if you didn't spend that whole day craving of that very moment." He framed the holy month as a moral and spiritual corrective, using the official channels of city government to amplify that message.
He went on to emphasize his religious identity in the role of mayor, stating, "Many asked me what it means to be the first Muslim mayor of our city, and in that question, there is an assumption that I am introducing our faith to the city as a whole, when in reality, our faith has been a part of this city for generations." Mamdani added, "The question of whether it's been seen is another matter entirely, but Muslims and New York City, they are intertwined."
Critics on X argued that the mayors use of government platforms to promote a specific faith undermines the long-standing American principle of church-state separation. One user asked, "Serious question: When did this blend of church and state become totally fine with the left?"
Others questioned whether similar treatment would be afforded to Christian or Jewish observances, suggesting a double standard in how public institutions handle religion. "Are you going to do these daily updates for every religions holidays? You wont. And you shouldnt be for yours, either" one user wrote, while another insisted, "What ever happened to separation of Church and State? Post this on a private account not the one of the NY Mayor."
Login