In a recent development that marks a significant turn in the notorious Theranos scandal, Elizabeth Holmes, the company's beleaguered CEO, suffered a blow in her legal battle as an appeals court denied her request to stay accessible.
At the same time, she attempted to challenge her conviction. A consequence of her fraudulent blood-testing scheme that offered her brief acclaim and wealth, Holmes now stares at the grim reality of prison life.
This news arrived on Tuesday following a parallel ruling from U.S. District Judge Edward Davila. In his order, he mandated Holmes to pay $452 million as restitution to the victims affected by her fraudulent acts. Holmes and her former boyfriend, Ramesh "Sunny" Balwani, an erstwhile top executive at Theranos, are jointly liable for this amount. Balwani is serving time after being found guilty of a broader range of charges in a distinct trial.
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals' decision on Holmes's plea to eschew prison was delivered nearly three weeks after she employed a last-ditch legal tactic to postpone the onset of her 11-year sentence. Previously, Judge Davila had commanded her to surrender to the authorities by April 27.
In the coming days, Davila is expected to announce a new date for Holmes, 39, to relinquish her current residence in San Diego and prison report. This impending sentence will see her separated from her partner, William "Billy" Evans, and their two young children, a one-year-old son, and a three-month-old daughter.
Holmes' recommended place of incarceration is a women's prison in Bryan, Texas, as suggested by Davila. The Federal Bureau of Prisons has yet to reveal whether they have accepted this recommendation or assigned Holmes to a different facility.
Balwani, aged 57, commenced his nearly 13-year prison term in April after being found guilty of 12 counts of fraud and conspiracy the previous July. His incarceration began last month in a Southern California prison following a failed attempt to stay out on bail while appealing his conviction.
Once the darling of Silicon Valley, Holmes was convicted in January on three charges of wire fraud and one conspiracy charge. The jury found her guilty of deceitfully duping investors with false claims about her company's blood-testing technology, which purportedly could diagnose diseases with only a few droplets of blood.
Originally indicted on 11 charges, Holmes was acquitted on four, with the jury failing to reach a verdict on the remaining three. Prosecutors had sought a 15-year sentence for her transgressions, describing the case as "one of the most substantial white collar offenses Silicon Valley or any other District has seen."
Holmes' defense sought mercy from the court, painting a picture of Holmes as a daughter and a mother capable of positively contributing to society in the future. Over 130 individuals, some with significant influence, such as Senator Cory Booker, sent letters to the judge vouching for her character.
The trial, lasting 46 days, exposed a culture of greed and hubris that has permeated Silicon Valley as technology's influence has grown exponentially over the past two decades.
Some of the most captivating moments of the trial arose when Holmes defended herself on the stand. She chronicled her journey, from founding Theranos as a teenager after dropping out of Stanford University in 2003 to claiming that Balwani abused her emotionally and sexually. Despite the company's egregious failures, Holmes maintained her belief in Theranos' potential to transform healthcare.
Holmes' audacious ambition attracted nearly $1 billion from prominent investors such as Oracle co-founder Larry Ellison and media tycoon Rupert Murdoch. However, the investors lost their money following a Wall Street Journal investigation and regulatory reviews that revealed dangerous deficiencies in Theranos' technology.
As part of the restitution, Judge Davila ruled that Holmes and Balwani owe Murdoch $125 million, the highest among the investors listed in his order. The restitution also necessitates that the Theranos co-conspirators pay $40 million to Walgreens. This company had become an investor and agreed to offer faulty blood tests in its pharmacies in 2013.
Safeway initially agreed to be a Theranos business partner before opting out and is owed another $14.5 million per the restitution order.
Holmes's legal team is persistently contesting her conviction, citing alleged errors and misconduct during her trial. They argue that the jury was so profoundly prejudiced by these oversights and abuses that Holmes should be permitted to stay out of prison while her appeal proceeds. This plea has been dismissed by both Davila and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.
Login