In a peculiar twist on the traditional image of Father Christmas, a museum in the United Kingdom has sparked controversy by suggesting that the iconic figure is too white, too male, and too judgmental.
The museum's guide to "decolonising" Santa Claus has raised eyebrows, as it calls for a more inclusive and understanding version of the man in red and white, particularly towards children deemed "naughty."
According to Breitbart, Brighton and Hove Museums published a blog post advocating for Santa to work alongside his elves on the production line, symbolizing equality among all. The museum also proposes that Mrs. Christmas should step into the limelight, reflecting a broader reassessment of Christmas traditions worldwide. This initiative comes after the museum received a substantial grant of 900,000 (approximately $1,207,915) from taxpayers in October.
The museum argues that Santa's traditional "naughty and nice" list perpetuates the notion that "the coloniser has the power to judge all people," and it is time to address the historical inaccuracies and harmful attitudes associated with this narrative.
Simone LaCorbinire, the museum's Joint Head of Culture Change, authored the post, challenging historical records that depict Father Christmas as a spirit of winter and goodwill dating back to the 15th century. Initially referenced in carols as "Sir Christmas," the character evolved into a symbol of Christmas feasting in the 17th century, particularly as a counter to Puritan bans on the holiday. The modern image of Santa Claus, as we know it today, emerged during the Victorian era, blending with the American Santa Claus figure.
The museum's blog post critiques the traditional portrayal of Santa, stating: "The tale of a white, Western Santa who judges all childrens behaviour has problems. As he visits each nation, he determines if the children deserve presents based on being naughty or nice. But who decided Santa should be the judge of childrens behaviour in every community?" LaCorbinire suggests that Santa should evolve into a "more diverse character who celebrates cultural exchange," proposing that stories depict him learning about and experiencing different cultures rather than judging them.
The post also advocates for the inclusion of "Mother Christmases," highlighting the intertwined nature of patriarchy and colonialism. This perspective has drawn criticism from some quarters, with senior Tory MP Sir Alec Shelbrooke expressing his disapproval. He remarked, "At a time of goodwill and festive cheer, it seems woke do-gooders would rather everybody was miserable. This is the worst possible use of taxpayer funds."
The debate over Santa's image reflects broader cultural discussions about tradition, inclusivity, and the role of historical narratives in shaping contemporary society. As Christmas continues to be reexamined, the conversation around Father Christmas serves as a microcosm of larger societal shifts and the ongoing dialogue about cultural representation and diversity.
Login