Tuesday's off-year elections signaled a notable Democratic resurgence, with sweeping victories in Virginia and New Jersey, progressive triumphs in New York City, and a favorable outcome on a redistricting ballot measure in California.
According to the Daily Caller, these results surpassed expectations, as pre-election polling had suggested much tighter contests in Virginia and New Jersey. The Democrats' strong performance has invigorated the party, prompting plans to leverage their 2025 successes into more challenging races in traditionally conservative states.
However, a closer examination of these victories reveals a more nuanced picture. Rather than indicating a broad revival of the Democratic Party, the data highlights the unique shortcomings of former Vice President Kamala Harris as a candidate.
Harris's 2024 defeat to President Donald Trump was not merely a structural issue. Despite her claims of insufficient time to implement her agenda, her loss was largely attributed to her unpopularity among voters, stemming from messaging missteps that alienated key swing groups.
Nationally, she underperformed compared to former President Joe Biden by approximately 7 million votes, erasing the gains Biden had made in 2020 among Independents and resulting in a 10-point swing in favor of Trump. Harris also struggled to attract the support of never-Trump Republicans. Despite holding rallies with anti-Trump figures like Liz Cheney, Trump managed to secure the moderate vote by a 5-point margin over Harris.
The Democratic victories can be attributed to several factors. Any candidate would have been more appealing than Harris in 2024, and many of the wins occurred in blue or purple states that are inherently more favorable to Democratic candidates. Additionally, Republicans often face challenges in off-year elections due to a significant portion of their base being low-propensity voters.
Nonetheless, Republicans must strategize on how to secure victories without Trump on the ballot. The economy will play a crucial role in the 2026 midterm elections. It would be imprudent for Democrats to view their 2025 successes as a template for the midterms.
In reality, these Democratic candidates were fortunate not to be burdened by Harris's unappealing personality, which could have otherwise hindered their electoral prospects.
Login