The tragic death of 4-year-old Jahmeik Modlin, found malnourished and hypothermic in a Harlem apartment, has sparked a wave of outrage and concern.
Jahmeik is the latest in a series of child maltreatment fatalities in the city, marking the sixth such death in the past three months. "It breaks our heart any time a child is abused, any time a child is harmed," expressed a visibly distressed Mayor Eric Adams in response to the news.
According to The New York Post, Jahmeik's family had prior interactions with the Administration for Childrens Services (ACS), mirroring the circumstances of other recent victims such as 11-month-old Jazeli Mirabel, 10-year-old Brian Santiago, and 5-year-old DeNeil Timberlake. The specifics of these interactions remain undisclosed. However, a neighbor's account paints a grim picture of an abusive domestic environment, with the father allegedly brandishing a knife while the mother barricaded herself within the apartment.
In the face of these heartrending tragedies, Mayor Adams pledged, Were going to do everything we can to give parents the support that they deserve. This statement, however, has been met with incredulity and anger. Critics argue that the focus should be on protecting children rather than supporting parents who have been charged with criminally negligent homicide for starving a child.
A mother of three who was present at the scene voiced her indignation to The Post: Get rid of both of the pieces of st the mom and the dad To not feed a kid? Thats not right. Yet, the prevailing narrative among city professionals seems to be one of parental support.
Jess Dannhauser, commissioner of the ACS, has been promoting his agency's plan to divert cases from official investigations towards its Collaborative Assessment, Response, Engagement & Support (CARES) system. The CARES initiative aims to combat racial disparities and promote social justice by encouraging families to devise their own solutions to their challenges. Additionally, ACS has introduced Family Enrichment Centers to foster social connection, and parental resilience.
In a move that has raised eyebrows, ACS is now providing parents with legal notices informing them that they are not obligated to allow ACS into their homes to investigate reports of child maltreatment. This shift in focus towards parents rather than children has led some to question whether the agency should be renamed the Administration for Parents Services.
The failure to protect vulnerable children is not limited to ACS. Nonprofits funded by the city have also subscribed to the belief that increased parental support would prevent such tragedies. Dr. Iesha Sekou, of Street Corner Resources, suggested that prevention could be achieved through increased neighborhood engagement and communication.
However, the case of Jahmeik Modlin suggests that more than just community engagement is needed. Neighbors reported rarely seeing Jahmeik's mother's four children, all under the age of 10, and never witnessing them attend school. Despite offers of food and clothing for the children, the mother consistently refused.
The ACS has recently launched a program discouraging teachers from reporting families whose children are not attending school or showing signs of needing more resources. This approach, critics argue, overlooks the reality that many parents who neglect or abuse their children are not merely impoverished but may be grappling with severe mental health issues or substance abuse.
The narrative that these parents are simply unaware of available services is pervasive, even in the media. For instance, PIX11 News included a list of resources such as the National Hunger Hotline and Temporary Housing Assistance in a story about Jahmeik, but failed to provide information on reporting suspected child abuse.
This reluctance to confront the harsh reality of child abuse and neglect extends even to the medical community. A recent article in JAMA Pediatrics suggested that pediatricians should rely on local resources like food pantries and housing assistance rather than calling Child Protective Services when they suspect a child is being neglected.
This widespread denial and avoidance of the issue is resulting in a failure to protect the most vulnerable members of our community. Government officials, nonprofit leaders, teachers, and even doctors are accused of turning a blind eye to the suffering of children, prioritizing the interests of the abusers over the abused. Amidst this systemic failure, the question remains: Who stands up for the children?
Login