In a surprising turn of events, California Governor Gavin Newsom has ignited a contentious battle over redistricting, seemingly without taking into account the potential unintended consequences.
The Democratic governor's decision came in response to Texas' recent redistricting, which resulted in a congressional map that favored Republicans more than those in California, Illinois, and other states. The Democrats had an opportunity to de-escalate the situation, accepting that they cannot always dictate the rules.
However, Newsom, with his presidential ambitions, chose to escalate the situation, triggering a redistricting arms race.
According to RedState, Newsom's decision to push California's already controversial maps to new extremes has led to a rapid unraveling of his plans. The governor's aggressive stance has prompted other states to consider redistricting, with Missouri, a traditionally red state, being one of several expected to follow suit. The result is a political war that the Democrats are ill-equipped to win.
President Donald Trump has indicated that Missouri is preparing to redistrict, potentially creating a 7-1 map in favor of Republicans. With the backing of the White House, it seems unlikely that moderate GOP members of the state legislature will be able to resist the push. While this may seem insignificant, the cumulative effect of these moves is substantial.
Texas, for instance, has added five GOP-leaning seats with its new map. California aimed to match this, but its new map is projected to yield only a four-seat pickup. With Missouri entering the fray, Republicans are poised to outpace the Democrats.
However, the situation could become even more complex if Illinois and New York decide to join the redistricting battle. Illinois, for instance, has already maximized its gerrymandering following the 2020 census, leaving Republicans with just three of its 17 seats. There is a limit to how much the lines can be redrawn without conceding territory.
New York faces legal obstacles to redistricting, and California is not exempt from these challenges. Newsom must navigate state laws that restrict redistricting to once a decade and adhere to a constitutionally-mandated "independent commission."
Even if these hurdles are overcome, other red states are ready to counterbalance any gains made by the Democrats. Florida, for example, experienced a heated redistricting battle during the last cycle, with Governor Ron DeSantis having to take drastic measures to secure a favorable map for Republicans. If Newsom believes DeSantis will not go to even greater lengths this time, he may be in for a surprise.
In essence, the Republicans have more opportunities to gerrymander across the country than the Democrats, making this a losing battle for the latter. While the Democrats' actions may earn them praise on networks like CNN, the end result will likely be more pickup opportunities for the GOP.
As the dust settles, the Democrats may find themselves wishing they had allowed the situation to end with Texas. This redistricting war, sparked by Governor Newsom's ambitions, serves as a stark reminder of the potential pitfalls of political maneuvering without careful consideration of the consequences.
Login