In a controversial move, a New Mexico judge has dismissed charges against 98 individuals who illegally crossed into a restricted area along the New Mexico border.
This strip of land, a 60-foot-wide stretch along the US-Mexico border, was designated a National Defense Area under the Trump administration, effectively making it part of the US Army Garrison Fort Huachuca.
However, Judge Gregory B. Wormuth has taken a different stance, dismissing charges against approximately 100 individuals who crossed into this area illegally. His argument is based on the premise that these individuals were unaware they were entering a restricted military base when they crossed the border.
The crossing into this restricted area is designed to carry more severe penalties than standard illegal border crossings.
Wormuth argued that the individuals should not be held accountable for breaking an additional law they were unaware of. "The United States provides no facts from which one could reasonably conclude that the defendant knew he was entering," Wormuth stated.
He further explained, "Requiring an intentional entry means that the defendant must know they were entering the military property. Indeed, not requiring knowledge of entry would again lead to absurd and unfair results."
According to The Post Millennial, Wormuth is also presiding over several other similar cases and has stated he did not find probable cause for the charges. Defense lawyers for the individuals argued that their clients "crossed between signs, arrived exhausted in the dark or were unable to read the warnings." The government has placed "Restricted Area" signs along the border at intervals, with the signs written in both English and Spanish.
One of the defense attorneys described the area as "just a bunch of desert," adding, "Theyre just coming over the same as usual, and all of a sudden, its military charges. Nobody knows whats going on." The attorney failed to acknowledge the fact that the individuals had already committed a crime by illegally crossing the border before entering the restricted area.
The government had filed misdemeanor charges against approximately 400 individuals, a move applauded by Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, who has been striving to reduce illegal border crossings. "When you cross illegally, you will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law," Hegseth stated during a visit to the area in April.
"They know we mean business. But they weren't counting on a national defense area. They weren't counting on effectively a military base along the border where our U.S. troops are now defending our border."
The charges against the individuals could have resulted in up to one year in prison, along with additional immigration-related penalties. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) expressed concern over the situation. "We see the government flexing their power, flexing their authorities. And we're concerned about the risk that this poses to everyone in our border communities," stated ACLU attorney Rebecca Sheff.
Despite the dismissal of their cases by Wormuth, the individuals may still face charges for illegally crossing the border and are likely to be deported. They remain in custody. Assistant federal defender Amanda Skinner commented, "If the government has the evidence to support the charges, theyre welcome to refile. Weve been convinced there was no probable cause." This case serves as a stark reminder of the ongoing debate surrounding immigration laws and the enforcement of these laws along the U.S.-Mexico border.
Login