In a recent address at Georgetown University, Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor expressed her concerns about the current state of the U.S. legal system, without directly naming President Donald Trump. She highlighted the "troubling" level of disregard for the courts, attorneys, and judges, which she believes is undermining the rule of law in the country.
According to Politico, Sotomayor, who is the senior liberal justice on the court, stated, "One of the things that's troubling so many right now is many of the standards that are being changed right now were norms that governed officials into what was right and wrong." She emphasized that the erosion of these norms is shaking the foundations of the rule of law, a cornerstone of American democracy.
The Trump administration has repeatedly sought the Supreme Court's intervention in cases where lower court judges have ruled against the President's policies on government cutbacks and deportations. These include a court order preventing the administration from dismissing thousands of probationary workers, a ruling by District of Columbia Judge James Boasberg that stops Trump from using an 18th-century law to deport alleged Venezuelan gang members, and attempts to limit district court judges from nationally blocking his policies.
Chief Justice John Roberts recently criticized Trump for his calls to impeach Boasberg and other judges who have ruled against him. Sotomayor's critique was also directed at the President's appointees and congressional supporters, many of whom are law degree holders who have echoed Trump's calls for impeachment and personally attacked judges obstructing the President's plans.
Sotomayor, in her conversation with Georgetown law Dean William Treanor, expressed her disappointment with law schools, stating, "They have not done enough to teach about our respect for the Constitution. The fact that some of our public leaders are lawyers advocating or making statements challenging the rule of law tells me that, fundamentally, our law schools are failing."
The Justice, who often finds herself in the minority in Supreme Court cases due to the 6-3 conservative majority, cited her dissent in the case of Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, which overturned the Roe v. Wade decision on the constitutional right to abortion. She sees this case as a reminder that court decisions can be temporary and subject to change.
"As we know from recent events, the court does change its mind, so, this is not without hope," Sotomayor said. She also warned that undermining judicial independence would further erode the rule of law. Appointed to the high court by President Barack Obama in 2009, Sotomayor emphasized, "We have to get up and explain and repeat and explain again why judicial independence is critical to everyone's freedom, because arbitrary power is just that, and it means that anyone is going to be subject to unfairness at someone else's whim."
Sotomayor's remarks underscore the importance of maintaining respect for the rule of law and the independence of the judiciary. As she rightly points out, the erosion of these principles could lead to the misuse of power and the potential for unfair treatment. The Justice's comments serve as a reminder that the legal system should be a bulwark against arbitrary power, not a tool for its exercise. Her words should resonate with all who value the principles of limited government and individual freedom, cornerstones of conservative thought.
Login